Johansen Louise Victoria
Faculty of Law, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Front Sociol. 2024 Dec 16;9:1457424. doi: 10.3389/fsoc.2024.1457424. eCollection 2024.
This paper explores how Danish legal professionals assess the trustworthiness of victims in criminal cases based on emotional expressions. It focuses on the alignment of these expressions with the nature of the crime, the social context, and the victims' social identities, and is based on findings from several ethnographic projects involving extensive observations of crime cases and interviews with criminal justice professionals. The research analyzes how victims' emotional expressions are scrutinized and interpreted within the context of Danish cultural norms, which favor "calm and quiet" behavior. Legal professionals define this behavior as specifically "Danish," and often contrast it to ethnic minorities' way of enacting emotions. Emotions are thus culturally and socially interpreted in courtroom settings, and I relate these findings to broader discussions about how emotions mediate, co-create and maintain systematic differences based on gender and ethnicity in legal decision-making. The study thus highlights the cultural and social dimensions of emotions in this legal setting and calls for greater awareness of how these factors influence the assessment of trustworthiness.
本文探讨丹麦法律专业人士如何根据情感表达来评估刑事案件中受害者的可信度。它着重于这些表达与犯罪性质、社会背景以及受害者社会身份的一致性,并基于几个民族志项目的研究结果,这些项目涉及对犯罪案件的广泛观察以及对刑事司法专业人士的访谈。该研究分析了在丹麦文化规范背景下,受害者的情感表达是如何被审视和解读的,丹麦文化规范推崇“冷静和安静”的行为。法律专业人士将这种行为明确界定为“丹麦式”,并经常将其与少数族裔表达情感的方式进行对比。因此,在法庭环境中,情感在文化和社会层面上得到解读,我将这些研究结果与关于情感如何在法律决策中基于性别和种族来调节、共同创造和维持系统性差异的更广泛讨论联系起来。这项研究因此突出了在这种法律环境中情感的文化和社会维度,并呼吁人们更加意识到这些因素是如何影响可信度评估的。