Alshammri Fahd, Abdulshakour Muhammed, Chen Lucy, Sheppard Rebekah, Kearney Josie, Petropoulos Jo-Anne, Bilgic Elif
Department of Pediatrics, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
Division of Pediatric Endocrinology, Department of Pediatrics, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada.
Clin Teach. 2025 Feb;22(1):e70011. doi: 10.1111/tct.70011.
Pediatric endocrinology education is a fundamental part of all pediatric endocrinology training. Hence, understanding the current methods used for training learners on skills required and understanding methods or topics that may be underexplored could help improve the quality of training.
This study aims to explore training and assessment strategies used in pediatric endocrinology training across medical education programs through a scoping review.
Search strategy was developed with a librarian, and bibliographic databases (e.g., MEDLINE and EMBASE) were searched from January 2005 to July 2024. Pilot screenings ensured consistent inclusion/exclusion decisions among reviewers. Full-text articles were included if they were related to pediatric endocrinology education and focused on medical learners.
We included 45 of 5814 sources of evidence for data extraction. Majority focused on knowledge of Type 1 and Type 2 diabetes and diabetes ketoacidosis (N = 18), followed by differences in sex development and pubertal assessment (N = 12). The most frequently used training method was through didactics. Additionally, the most frequently used assessment measures included knowledge tests (N = 25). Also, a limited number of studies targeted obesity (N = 2), gender care (N = 3), thyroid (N = 1) and hypoglycaemia (N = 1), and no studies targeted common topics such as bone health and adrenal insufficiency.
This review reveals the current emphasis on diabetes-related topics and traditional teaching in pediatric endocrinology education. It suggests a need for more innovative methods, like simulation-based learning and varied assessment techniques, to better equip trainees. Addressing these gaps can improve trainee confidence, patient care, and health outcomes for children with endocrine disorders.
儿科内分泌学教育是所有儿科内分泌学培训的重要组成部分。因此,了解当前用于培训学习者所需技能的方法,并了解可能未得到充分探索的方法或主题,有助于提高培训质量。
本研究旨在通过范围综述,探索医学教育项目中儿科内分泌学培训所采用的培训和评估策略。
与一名图书馆员共同制定检索策略,并检索了2005年1月至2024年7月的文献数据库(如MEDLINE和EMBASE)。预筛选确保了评审人员之间纳入/排除决策的一致性。如果全文文章与儿科内分泌学教育相关且聚焦于医学学习者,则将其纳入。
我们从5814个证据来源中纳入了45个进行数据提取。大多数研究聚焦于1型和2型糖尿病以及糖尿病酮症酸中毒的知识(N = 18),其次是性发育差异和青春期评估(N = 12)。最常用的培训方法是讲授法。此外,最常用的评估措施包括知识测试(N = 25)。此外,针对肥胖(N = 2)、性别护理(N = 3)、甲状腺(N = 1)和低血糖(N = 1)的研究数量有限,没有研究针对骨骼健康和肾上腺功能不全等常见主题。
本综述揭示了儿科内分泌学教育目前对糖尿病相关主题和传统教学的重视。这表明需要更多创新方法,如基于模拟的学习和多样化的评估技术,以使学员更好地做好准备。填补这些空白可以提高学员的信心、患者护理水平以及内分泌疾病患儿的健康结局。