MacDonald David, Stojkova Biljana Jonoska, Reitzik Sabina
Division of Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology, Faculty of Dentistry, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada.
Department of Statistics, Applied Statistics and Data Science Group, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada.
Imaging Sci Dent. 2024 Dec;54(4):336-344. doi: 10.5624/isd.20240062. Epub 2024 Aug 12.
This study aimed to evaluate the quality of clinically indicated digital dental panoramic radiographs (DPRs) of children with mixed dentition. Despite the likely widespread use of this modality, recent research detailing errors on DPRs is scarce.
A consecutive case series was performed, including 178 DPRs from patients aged 6 to 12 years. Each DPR was reviewed for 10 distinct errors. The findings were analyzed to identify potential solutions.
Nearly three-quarters of the DPRs contained multiple errors. Linear regression analysis indicated that the number of errors decreased with increasing patient age; however, this trend was not statistically significant. Notably, 3 groups of errors (2 errors each) frequently appeared together on the same DPR. When similar errors were grouped, the error incidence decreased significantly with age. Both leftward head tilting and rightward head rotation were observed, likely attributable to the design of the DPR room and the door location. The inter-rater and intra-rater reliability agreements were deemed "substantial" or "almost perfect, beyond chance" for the detection of most errors, particularly the most frequent types, which involved the "chin," "tongue," and "lips-open" positions.
As a pediatric patient ages, the number of DPR errors decreases. The results suggest several pre-exposure strategies that could reduce the error rate. These include, monitoring for a "lips-open" position as an indicator of a potential "tongue" error (occluding the palate-glossal space), and implementing dry runs. Asymmetries observed on DPR must be documented and should prompt re-examination, as they may be genuine.
本研究旨在评估混合牙列期儿童临床指征性数字化牙科全景X线片(DPR)的质量。尽管这种检查方式可能已广泛应用,但近期详细描述DPR错误的研究却很少。
进行了一项连续病例系列研究,纳入了178例6至12岁患者的DPR。对每张DPR检查10种不同的错误。分析研究结果以确定潜在的解决方法。
近四分之三的DPR包含多种错误。线性回归分析表明,错误数量随患者年龄增加而减少;然而,这种趋势无统计学意义。值得注意的是,3组错误(每组2个错误)经常在同一张DPR上同时出现。当将相似错误分组时,错误发生率随年龄显著降低。观察到头部向左倾斜和向右旋转,这可能归因于DPR检查室的设计和门的位置。对于大多数错误的检测,尤其是涉及“下巴”“舌头”和“嘴唇张开”位置的最常见类型错误,评估者间和评估者内的可靠性一致性被认为是“高度一致”或“几乎完美,绝非偶然”。
随着儿科患者年龄增长,DPR错误数量减少。研究结果提示了几种可降低错误率的曝光前策略。这些策略包括,监测“嘴唇张开”位置作为潜在“舌头”错误(遮挡腭舌间隙)的指标,以及进行预演。DPR上观察到的不对称情况必须记录下来,并且应促使重新检查,因为它们可能是真实存在的。