Careau Juliette, Bélair Justin, Whitley Rob
Department of Psychiatry, Douglas Research Centre, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
JB Statistical Consulting, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
Can J Psychiatry. 2025 Feb;70(2):98-108. doi: 10.1177/07067437241309677. Epub 2025 Jan 6.
Evidence suggests that the media can play a role in preventing suicide, as well as contributing to suicide contagion. As such, the primary objective is to assess adherence to responsible reporting of suicide recommendations in news articles about suicide over time. A secondary objective is to assess whether reporting changed significantly during the COVID-19 pandemic. The tertiary objective is to assess overall patterns regarding types of suicide reported.
We collected news articles with the keyword "suicide" from 47 Canadian news sources between April 1, 2019, and March 31, 2023. Articles were coded for adherence to key responsible reporting of suicide guidelines. Frequency counts and percentages of adherence were calculated for all key variables. Time series analyses using a Generalized Linear Autoregressive Moving Average model assessed for adherence trends over time, including measuring for any changes during the COVID-19 years.
Study procedures resulted in 3,232 coded news articles. Overall, the results indicate that adherence to the guidelines has moderately improved over the course of the 4-year period. This is especially true for recommendations regarding avoiding putatively harmful content, such as detailed descriptions of the suicide method. Similar improvements were seen in adherence to guidelines related to the inclusion of putatively helpful content, with significantly more articles providing help-seeking information. However, in the final year of the study, less than a third of articles included educational content about suicide, help-seeking information, or quotes from suicide experts. Reporting of suicide during the COVID-19 period showed some positive improvements; however, these were not sustained after the pandemic ended.
On the plus side, adherence to responsible suicide reporting guidelines improved over the 4-year period, especially for recommendations concerning putatively helpful content. However, there remains room for improvement regarding the inclusion of putatively protective content such as including help-seeking information, educating about suicide, and quoting experts.
有证据表明,媒体在预防自杀方面可发挥作用,同时也可能导致自杀传染。因此,主要目的是评估随着时间推移,新闻报道中关于自杀的文章对负责任报道自杀建议的遵守情况。次要目的是评估在新冠疫情期间报道是否有显著变化。第三个目的是评估所报道自杀类型的总体模式。
我们从47个加拿大新闻来源收集了2019年4月1日至2023年3月31日期间关键词为“自杀”的新闻文章。文章根据遵守自杀关键负责任报道指南的情况进行编码。计算所有关键变量的频率计数和遵守百分比。使用广义线性自回归移动平均模型进行时间序列分析,以评估随时间的遵守趋势,包括衡量新冠疫情期间的任何变化。
研究程序产生了3232篇编码新闻文章。总体而言,结果表明在4年期间,遵守指南情况有适度改善。对于避免可能有害内容(如自杀方法的详细描述)的建议尤其如此。在遵守与纳入可能有帮助内容相关的指南方面也有类似改善,提供寻求帮助信息的文章显著增多。然而,在研究的最后一年,不到三分之一的文章包含关于自杀的教育内容、寻求帮助信息或自杀专家的引述。新冠疫情期间的自杀报道有一些积极改善;然而,疫情结束后这些改善未能持续。
从积极方面来看,在4年期间对负责任自杀报道指南的遵守情况有所改善,特别是对于有关可能有帮助内容的建议。然而,在纳入可能具有保护作用的内容(如包括寻求帮助信息、开展自杀教育和引用专家观点)方面仍有改进空间。