Rankin Naomi, Saiyed Samee, Du Hongru, Gardner Lauren M
Department of Civil and Systems Engineering, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, USA.
Department of Civil and Systems Engineering, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, USA.
Sci Total Environ. 2025 Jan 15;960:178172. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2024.178172. Epub 2025 Jan 6.
The COVID-19 pandemic highlighted shortcomings in forecasting models, such as unreliable inputs/outputs and poor performance at critical points. As COVID-19 remains a threat, it is imperative to improve current forecasting approaches by incorporating reliable data and alternative forecasting targets to better inform decision-makers. Wastewater-based epidemiology (WBE) has emerged as a viable method to track COVID-19 transmission, offering a more reliable metric than reported cases for forecasting critical outcomes like hospitalizations. Recognizing the natural alignment of wastewater systems with city structures, ideal for leveraging WBE data, this study introduces a multi-city, wastewater-based forecasting model to categorically predict COVID-19 hospitalizations. Using hospitalization and COVID-19 wastewater data for six US cities, accompanied by other epidemiological variables, we develop a Generalized Additive Model (GAM) to generate two categorization types. The Hospitaization Capacity Risk Categorization (HCR) predicts the burden on the healthcare system based on the number of available hospital beds in a city. The Hospitalization Rate Trend (HRT) Categorization predicts the trajectory of this burden based on the growth rate of COVID-19 hospitalizations. Using these categorical thresholds, we create probabilistic forecasts to retrospectively predict the risk and trend category of six cities over a 20-month period for 1, 2, and 3 week forecasting windows. We also propose a new methodology to measure forecasting model performance at change points, or time periods where sudden changes in outbreak dynamics occurred. We also explore the influence of wastewater as a predictor for hospitalizations, showing its inclusion positively impacts the model's performance. With this categorical forecasting study, we are able to predict hospital capacity risk and disease trends in a novel and useful way, giving city decision-makers a new tool to predict COVID-19 hospitalizations.
新冠疫情凸显了预测模型的缺陷,比如输入/输出不可靠以及在关键点表现不佳。由于新冠疫情仍然构成威胁,当务之急是通过纳入可靠数据和采用替代预测指标来改进当前的预测方法,以便为决策者提供更充分的信息。基于废水的流行病学(WBE)已成为追踪新冠病毒传播的一种可行方法,它提供了一种比报告病例更可靠的指标,用于预测诸如住院等关键结果。认识到废水系统与城市结构的天然契合性,这非常适合利用WBE数据,本研究引入了一种基于多城市废水的预测模型,用于分类预测新冠住院情况。利用美国六个城市的住院和新冠废水数据,以及其他流行病学变量,我们开发了一个广义相加模型(GAM)来生成两种分类类型。住院容量风险分类(HCR)根据城市中可用病床数量预测医疗系统的负担。住院率趋势(HRT)分类根据新冠住院人数的增长率预测这种负担的变化轨迹。利用这些分类阈值,我们创建概率预测,以回顾性预测六个城市在20个月期间1周、2周和3周预测窗口的风险和趋势类别。我们还提出了一种新方法来衡量预测模型在变化点(即疫情动态突然变化的时间段)的性能。我们还探讨了废水作为住院预测指标的影响,结果表明将其纳入对模型性能有积极影响。通过这项分类预测研究,我们能够以一种新颖且有用的方式预测医院容量风险和疾病趋势,为城市决策者提供了一个预测新冠住院情况的新工具。