Chauhadry Imran A, Soofi Sajid Bashir, Sajid Muhammad, Ali Rafey, Khan Ahmad, Naqvi Syeda Kanza, Hussain Imtiaz, Umer Muhammad, Bhutta Zulfiqar A
Centre of Excellence in Women and Child Health, Aga Khan University, Karachi 74800, Pakistan.
Department of Pediatrics & Child Health, Aga Khan University, Karachi 74800, Pakistan.
Vaccines (Basel). 2024 Nov 28;12(12):1340. doi: 10.3390/vaccines12121340.
Immunization saves millions of lives, and globally, vaccines have significantly contributed to reducing mortality and morbidity due to more than 20 life-threatening illnesses. However, there are considerable disparities in vaccination coverage among countries and within populations. This study evaluates the reduction in disparities in vaccination coverage across various socio-economic groups by adopting an integrated community-engagement approach combined with maternal and child health services through mobile health camps. This secondary analysis is based on a community-based demonstration project conducted between 2014 and 2016 across 146 union councils in polio high-risk districts of Sindh, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) and Baluchistan in Pakistan. The intervention involved structured community engagement and mobile health camps providing routine immunization alongside maternal and child health services. Data were collected through cross-sectional independent surveys using the WHO two-stage cluster technique at the baseline and the endline, covering over 120,000 children under 5 years old. Four key outcome indicators were analyzed: fully vaccinated children, under-immunized children, unvaccinated children, and polio zero-dose children for equity in vaccine uptake. The proportion of fully vaccinated children increased in the lowest wealth quintile from 28.5% (26.7%, 30.3%) at the baseline to 51.6% (49.5%, 53.8%) at the endline. In comparison, the increase in the richest quantities was 16.2% (14.0%, 18.4%) from the baseline 56.4% (54.6%, 58.2%) to the endline 72.7% (71.1%, 74.2%). Under-vaccination dropped by 10.2% (95% CI: -11.4%, -9.1%), with the poorest quintile showing an 11.8% reduction. The gap between the highest and lowest wealth quintiles in full immunization narrowed by 6.9%, from 27.9% to 21.0% at the baseline and the endline, respectively. The prevalence of zero-dose children significantly decreased across all quintiles, with the highest reduction observed in the lowest quintile of -11.3% (-13.6%, -9.1%). The difference between the highest and lowest wealth quintiles reduced from 6.2% to 3.8%. A significant reduction in polio zero-dose children was achieved, as 13.5% (95% CI: -14.8%, -12.2%), from 29.2% (95% CI: 28.0%, 30.3%) to 15.6% (14.8%, 16.5%). This study shows that integrating community engagement with maternal and child health services through health camps can significantly enhance immunization coverage and reduce wealth-based disparities in high-risk, hard-to-reach areas. The approach improved coverage for zero-dose and fully vaccinated children, suggesting a potential for scaling in regions with access issues, conflict, and vaccine hesitancy.
免疫接种拯救了数百万人的生命,在全球范围内,疫苗对降低20多种危及生命疾病导致的死亡率和发病率做出了重大贡献。然而,各国之间以及人群内部的疫苗接种覆盖率存在相当大的差距。本研究通过采用综合社区参与方法,并通过流动健康营将其与母婴健康服务相结合,评估不同社会经济群体之间疫苗接种覆盖率差距的缩小情况。这项二次分析基于2014年至2016年期间在巴基斯坦信德省、开伯尔-普赫图赫瓦省(KP)和俾路支省脊髓灰质炎高危地区的146个联合委员会开展的一项基于社区的示范项目。干预措施包括结构化社区参与和流动健康营,这些健康营在提供母婴健康服务的同时也提供常规免疫接种。在基线和终线时,通过使用世卫组织两阶段整群抽样技术进行横断面独立调查收集数据,覆盖了超过120000名5岁以下儿童。分析了四个关键结果指标:完全接种疫苗的儿童、未充分免疫的儿童、未接种疫苗的儿童以及脊髓灰质炎零剂次儿童,以评估疫苗接种的公平性。完全接种疫苗的儿童在最贫困财富五分位中的比例从基线时的28.5%(26.7%,30.3%)增加到终线时的51.6%(49.5%,53.8%)。相比之下,最富裕五分位中的比例从基线时的56.4%(54.6%,58.2%)增加到终线时的72.7%(71.1%,74.2%),增幅为16.2%(14.0%,18.4%)。未充分接种疫苗的比例下降了10.2%(95%置信区间:-11.4%,-9.1%),最贫困五分位下降了11.8%。完全免疫中最富裕和最贫困财富五分位之间的差距缩小了6.9%,分别从基线时的27.9%降至终线时的21.0%。所有五分位中零剂次儿童的患病率均显著下降,在最贫困五分位中下降幅度最大,为-11.3%(-13.6%,-9.1%)。最富裕和最贫困财富五分位之间的差异从6.2%降至3.8%。脊髓灰质炎零剂次儿童显著减少,从29.2%(95%置信区间:28.0%,3