Hwang Yun Tae, Cheung Sau Chi, Piguet Olivier, Burrell James R, Leyton Cristian E
Brain and Mind Centre, The University of Sydney, Camperdown, NSW, Australia.
Gosford Hospital, Gosford, NSW, Australia.
J Clin Neurol. 2025 Jan;21(1):3-12. doi: 10.3988/jcn.2023.0451.
Nonfluent variant primary progressive aphasia (nfvPPA) is a neurodegenerative disorder characterized by the progressive deterioration of language functions that typically appears with atrophy predominating in the left peri-insular region (left-nfvPPA) on imaging. While both left-dominant and right-dominant presentations have been reported in semantic variant primary progressive aphasia, the other language presentation of frontotemporal dementia, no case series of nfvPPA with predominantly right-sided atrophy of the peri-insular region (right-nfvPPA) have been reported previously. This study explored whether such entities exist and what their clinical features might be.
A retrospective review of brain imaging data obtained from an established cohort of patients diagnosed with nfvPPA was performed to identify right-nfvPPA cases, followed by detailed analyses of their clinical profiles and imaging results compared to matched typical left-nfvPPA cases and healthy control group.
Four of 55 individuals meeting the consensus diagnostic criteria for nfvPPA demonstrated right-nfvPPA. No significant differences were noted in their clinical and neuropsychological profiles. Detailed imaging analyses demonstrated that the individuals with right-nfvPPA did not demonstrate atrophy of the anterior cingulate gyrus, unlike those in the left-nfvPPA group.
This study has revealed several intriguing differences between right-nfvPPA and left-nfvPPA, particularly in the prevalence of impairments in motor speech and naming as well as imaging differences. These findings warrant further exploration in a larger cohort to improve our understanding of neural network organization and its dysfunction in neurodegenerative disorders.
非流畅型原发性进行性失语(nfvPPA)是一种神经退行性疾病,其特征为语言功能逐渐衰退,影像学检查通常显示左侧岛周区域萎缩为主(左nfvPPA)。虽然在语义变异型原发性进行性失语(额颞叶痴呆的另一种语言表现形式)中已报道了左侧优势和右侧优势的表现,但此前尚未有关于岛周区域主要为右侧萎缩的nfvPPA(右nfvPPA)病例系列报道。本研究探讨了此类病例是否存在及其临床特征可能是什么。
对从已确诊为nfvPPA的既定队列患者中获取的脑成像数据进行回顾性分析,以识别右nfvPPA病例,随后与匹配的典型左nfvPPA病例和健康对照组相比,详细分析其临床特征和影像学结果。
55名符合nfvPPA共识诊断标准的个体中有4例表现为右nfvPPA。其临床和神经心理学特征未发现显著差异。详细的影像学分析表明,与左nfvPPA组不同,右nfvPPA个体未显示前扣带回萎缩。
本研究揭示了右nfvPPA和左nfvPPA之间的几个有趣差异,特别是在运动性言语和命名障碍的发生率以及影像学差异方面。这些发现值得在更大的队列中进一步探索,以增进我们对神经退行性疾病中神经网络组织及其功能障碍的理解。