Cheng Qinglu, Fattah Rifqi Abdul, Susilo Dwidjo, Satrya Aryana, Haemmerli Manon, Kosen Soewarta, Novitasari Danty, Puteri Gemala Chairunnisa, Adawiyah Eviati, Hayen Andrew, Mills Anne, Tangcharoensathien Viroj, Jan Stephen, Thabrany Hasbullah, Asante Augustine, Wiseman Virginia
Kirby Institute, University of New South Wales, Sydney, Australia.
Kirby Institute, UNSW Australia, Level 6, Wallace Wurth Building, High Street, Kensington, 2052, NSW, Australia.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2025 Jan 9;25(1):48. doi: 10.1186/s12913-024-11951-8.
Indonesia has implemented a series of healthcare reforms including its national health insurance scheme (Jaminan Kesehatan Nasional, JKN) to achieve universal health coverage. However, there is evidence of inequitable healthcare utilization in Indonesia, raising concerns that the poor might not be benefiting fully from government subsidies. This study aims to identify factors affecting healthcare utilization in Indonesia.
This study analysed cross-sectional survey data collected by the "Equity and Health Care Financing in Indonesia" (ENHANCE) Study. Andersen's behavioural model of health services use was adopted as a framework for understanding healthcare utilization in Indonesia. Sociodemographic variables were categorized into predisposing, enabling and need factors. Outcome measures included the utilization of primary and secondary health services. Multi-level logistic regression models were run to examine factors associated with each type of health service utilization.
Of the 31,864 individuals included in the ENHANCE survey, around 14% had used outpatient services in the past month. Fewer than 5% of the study population had visited hospitals for inpatient care and about 23% used maternal and child health services in the past 12 months. Age, gender and self-rated health were key determinants of health services utilization. No significant differences in primary care utilization were found among people with different insurance status, but people who received subsidised premiums under the JKN were more likely to receive primary care from public health facilities and less likely from private health facilities. Compared to people who pay JKN insurance premiums themselves, the uninsured and those whose premiums were subsidised by the government were less likely to visit public and private hospitals when other factors were controlled.
This study demonstrates that the distribution of healthcare utilization in Indonesia is largely equitable as predisposing factors (age and gender) and health need were found to greatly influence the utilization of different types of health services. However, enabling factors such as health insurance status were also found to be associated with inequity in utilization of hospital services. Further policy actions regarding resource allocation and health service planning are warranted to achieve a more equitable pattern of health service use in Indonesia.
印度尼西亚已实施了一系列医疗改革,包括其国家医疗保险计划(全民健康保险,JKN),以实现全民健康覆盖。然而,有证据表明印度尼西亚存在医疗服务利用不平等的情况,这引发了人们对穷人可能无法充分受益于政府补贴的担忧。本研究旨在确定影响印度尼西亚医疗服务利用的因素。
本研究分析了“印度尼西亚的公平与医疗保健筹资”(ENHANCE)研究收集的横断面调查数据。采用安德森的卫生服务利用行为模型作为理解印度尼西亚医疗服务利用的框架。社会人口学变量被分为易患因素、促成因素和需求因素。结果指标包括初级和二级卫生服务的利用情况。运行多水平逻辑回归模型以检查与每种类型的卫生服务利用相关的因素。
在ENHANCE调查纳入的31864人中,约14%的人在过去一个月使用过门诊服务。不到5%的研究人群因住院治疗去过医院,约23%的人在过去12个月使用过母婴保健服务。年龄、性别和自我评估的健康状况是卫生服务利用的关键决定因素。不同保险状况的人群在初级保健利用方面未发现显著差异,但在JKN下获得保费补贴的人更有可能从公共卫生机构获得初级保健,而从私立卫生机构获得初级保健的可能性较小。与自己支付JKN保险费的人相比,在控制其他因素后,未参保者和保费由政府补贴的人前往公立和私立医院就诊的可能性较小。
本研究表明,印度尼西亚医疗服务利用的分布在很大程度上是公平的,因为易患因素(年龄和性别)和健康需求被发现对不同类型卫生服务的利用有很大影响。然而,也发现诸如健康保险状况等促成因素与医院服务利用的不平等有关。有必要采取进一步的政策行动,以进行资源分配和卫生服务规划,从而在印度尼西亚实现更公平的卫生服务利用模式。