Damoiseaux P, Lacroix A, Assal J P
Diabete Metab. 1985 Feb;11(1):9-14.
In order to be fully therapeutic diabetes education should allow the patient to understand the mechanisms of the illness as well as the steps to be taken to achieve optimal treatment. In the course of their classes health care personnel ask diabetic patients questions with the intention of encouraging their participation. An education specialist has analysed the use of these questions: their number, their type and their functions' were noted. A) By type of question we refer to the various answers possible. Two groups can be distinguished: 1) limited number of answers possible as the result of a closed question, 2) multiple answers possible as the result of an open question. B) By function of question we refer to the cognitive effect a question may have on the patient. Again two categories can be described. In the first case numbers, terminology or facts learnt by heart; this being the result of questions of simple knowledge. In the second case, the establishment of relationships between facts as well as the solving of problem situations are encouraged by questions of understanding. The study shows that health care personnel tend to put forward closed rather than open questions. Regarding the function of the question most of them aim at simple repetition. Few activate the thinking process. As a result of the pedagogical training our team received concerning the use of questions in patient education an increase in the number of open questions and of questions of understanding was noted. These questions encourage the thinking process and the solving of problems encountered by the patient in the treatment of his/her diabetes.
为了达到充分的治疗效果,糖尿病教育应使患者了解疾病机制以及实现最佳治疗所需采取的步骤。在课程过程中,医护人员向糖尿病患者提问,旨在鼓励他们参与。一位教育专家分析了这些问题的使用情况:记录了问题的数量、类型及其功能。A)就问题类型而言,我们指的是可能的各种答案。可分为两组:1)封闭式问题导致答案数量有限,2)开放式问题导致答案多样。B)就问题功能而言,我们指的是问题可能对患者产生的认知效果。同样可分为两类。第一种情况是记忆数字、术语或事实,这是简单知识问题的结果。第二种情况是理解性问题鼓励建立事实之间的联系并解决问题情境。研究表明,医护人员倾向于提出封闭式问题而非开放式问题。就问题功能而言,大多数问题旨在简单重复。很少有问题能激发思维过程。由于我们团队接受了关于在患者教育中使用问题的教学培训,发现开放式问题和理解性问题的数量有所增加。这些问题鼓励患者在治疗糖尿病过程中的思维过程和问题解决。