Maini Rijul S, Jelneck Savannah L, Zimmerman William B
Department of Osteopathic Medicine, Michigan State University College of Osteopathic Medicine, East Lansing, USA.
Cureus. 2024 Dec 11;16(12):e75529. doi: 10.7759/cureus.75529. eCollection 2024 Dec.
The percentage of practicing female plastic surgeons in the United States is notably low. This narrative review sought to identify prominent barriers affecting women's entry and success in plastic surgery. A literature search was conducted using the National Library of Medicine from 2013 to 2023, using MeSH terms of gender disparity and plastic surgery. Included publications were peer-reviewed articles and systematic reviews evaluating gender disparity in plastic surgery, examining experiences, challenges, or opportunities for female plastic surgeons. Excluded publications did not include data gathered from the United States, included other minorities, or did not focus on plastic surgery. Overall, 191 papers were identified, with 14 papers being selected for this review. Early barriers identified before residency training include the lack of female mentors and the underrepresentation of female presenters at national plastic surgery conferences, with females comprising only 29% of presenters and 16% of abstract senior authors at national plastic surgery conferences between 2014 and 2015. During residency training, the most prominent barrier is pregnancy, with 73% of women delaying childbearing during residency and only 39% of men reporting the same. A second barrier during training includes gender disparity in the number of research publications, with females publishing 8.89 ± 0.97 publications during residency and males publishing 12.46 ± 1.08 publications (p = 0.0394). After residency training, evidence of barriers to career advancement includes poor representation of women in higher academic positions, such as program chairs and directors, with female representation of 9.2% and 13.1%, respectively, and gender disparity in industry payments. Systemic barriers before, during, and after plastic surgery residency training seem to influence the representation of women in plastic surgery at all levels. These barriers should be addressed to increase the number of practicing female plastic surgeons and diversify the field.
美国执业女整形外科医生的比例明显较低。这篇叙述性综述旨在找出影响女性进入整形外科并取得成功的主要障碍。利用美国国立医学图书馆,在2013年至2023年期间进行了文献检索,使用了性别差异和整形外科的医学主题词。纳入的出版物为同行评审文章和系统评价,评估整形外科中的性别差异,考察女整形外科医生的经历、挑战或机遇。排除的出版物未包括从美国收集的数据、包括其他少数群体的数据或未聚焦于整形外科的数据。总体而言,共识别出191篇论文,其中14篇被选入本综述。在住院医师培训之前发现的早期障碍包括缺乏女性导师以及在全国整形外科会议上女性演讲者的代表性不足,在2014年至2015年期间的全国整形外科会议上,女性仅占演讲者的29%,占摘要高级作者的16%。在住院医师培训期间,最突出的障碍是怀孕,73%的女性在住院医师培训期间推迟生育,而只有39%的男性报告有同样情况。培训期间的第二个障碍包括研究出版物数量上的性别差异,女性在住院医师培训期间发表8.89±0.97篇出版物,男性发表12.46±1.08篇出版物(p = 0.0394)。住院医师培训结束后,职业发展障碍的证据包括女性在较高学术职位(如项目主任和科室主任)中的代表性不佳,分别为9.2%和13.1%,以及行业报酬方面的性别差异。整形外科住院医师培训之前、期间和之后的系统性障碍似乎在各个层面影响着女性在整形外科领域的代表性。应解决这些障碍,以增加执业女整形外科医生的数量并使该领域多样化。