Kavanagh B F, Ilstrup D M, Fitzgerald R H
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1985 Apr;67(4):517-26.
Two hundred and ten hips in 206 patients who had an initial total hip arthroplasty performed at the Mayo Clinic between 1969 and 1978 required revision of the arthroplasty at the Mayo Clinic for reasons other than infection. One hundred and sixty-two of the patients (166 hips) were followed both clinically and roentgenographically for two years or more. One hundred and forty-five (90 per cent) reported that they had improvement after the surgical revision. Complications that occurred with revision included deep sepsis, superficial would infection, dislocation, intraoperative femoral fracture, and postoperative femoral fracture. Roentgenographic analysis showed probable loosening in thirty-three acetabular components (20.1 per cent) and seventy-two femoral components (44 per cent). Symptomatic loosening (moderate to severe pain and probable roentgenographic loosening) was seen in thirty-five patients. Eight patients required a second revision for this reason, and seven others required a second revision for other reasons. Modified Harris hip scores, calculated for 108 hips, showed a good or excellent result in sixty-seven hips (62 per cent), a fair result in twelve (11 per cent), and a poor result in twenty-nine (27 per cent). Using a new Mayo Clinic hip score that incorporates roentgenographic data (which will be described) in the evaluation of 165 revised hips, there was a good or excellent result in eighty-five (52 per cent), a fair result in thirty-two (19 per cent), and a poor result in forty-eight hips (29 per cent). Although 90 per cent of the patients thought that their condition had improved, the high incidence of roentgenographic signs of probable loosening of a component is of serious concern.
1969年至1978年间在梅奥诊所首次接受全髋关节置换术的206例患者共210髋,因感染以外的原因需要在梅奥诊所进行关节置换翻修。其中162例患者(166髋)接受了至少两年的临床和影像学随访。145例(90%)患者报告称翻修手术后病情有所改善。翻修手术出现的并发症包括深部脓毒症、浅表伤口感染、脱位、术中股骨骨折和术后股骨骨折。影像学分析显示,33个髋臼假体(20.1%)和72个股骨假体(44%)可能出现松动。35例患者出现有症状的松动(中度至重度疼痛且影像学显示可能松动)。8例患者因此需要二次翻修,另外7例患者因其他原因需要二次翻修。对108髋计算改良Harris髋关节评分,结果显示67髋(62%)为优或良,12髋(11%)为一般,29髋(27%)为差。采用梅奥诊所新的髋关节评分系统(该评分系统在评估中纳入了影像学数据,具体内容将另行描述)对165例翻修髋进行评估,结果显示85髋(52%)为优或良,32髋(19%)为一般,48髋(29%)为差。尽管90%的患者认为病情有所改善,但假体可能松动的影像学表现的高发生率仍令人严重担忧。