Baumrin Emily, Pidala Joseph, Mitchell Sandra A, Onstad Lynn, Lee Stephanie J
Department of Dermatology, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA.
Department of Blood and Marrow Transplantation and Cellular Immunotherapy, Moffitt Cancer Center and Research Institute, Tampa, FL.
Blood. 2025 Mar 20;145(12):1321-1332. doi: 10.1182/blood.2024027334.
Sclerosis is a highly morbid manifestation of chronic graft-versus-host disease (cGVHD), associated with distressing symptoms and significant long-term disability. A patient-reported outcome (PRO) measure for cGVHD-associated sclerosis is essential to advance therapeutic trials. We aimed to develop a PRO for adults with cGVHD-associated sclerosis and evaluate and refine its content validity. Adults aged ≥18 years with cGVHD-associated sclerosis participated in semistructured interviews to identify salient symptoms and functions. Sclerosis-relevant symptoms and functions from existing PROs were also used to prompt discussion of topics not spontaneously mentioned. Symptoms and functions (subcodes) of importance were clustered and mapped to overarching domains (codes) using inductive analysis, and candidate items were developed. Cognitive interviews were used to evaluate content validity of the items, response options, recall period, and respondent instructions. Thirty-six open-ended interviews, conducted to saturation, revealed the breadth of the patient experience with cGVHD-associated sclerosis including 5 overarching domains: (1) skin changes, (2) symptoms, (3) emotional and social functioning, (4) mobility restrictions, and (5) activity limitations. A pool of 54 items was tested and iteratively refined through cognitive debriefing interviews (n = 25). Phrasing changes were made to improve relevance and comprehension. One item was removed, and 2 items were added to address respondent feedback, resulting in 55 items. Results support the relevance, comprehensibility, and comprehensiveness of the provisional Lee Symptom Scale-Skin Sclerosis. Concept elicitation and cognitive interviewing have informed the development of the Lee Symptom Scale-Skin Sclerosis. Psychometric testing and determination of minimal clinically important differences are underway in an external cohort to validate the PROs.
硬化是慢性移植物抗宿主病(cGVHD)的一种高发病率表现,伴有令人痛苦的症状和严重的长期残疾。针对cGVHD相关硬化的患者报告结局(PRO)测量对于推进治疗试验至关重要。我们旨在为患有cGVHD相关硬化的成年人开发一种PRO,并评估和完善其内容效度。年龄≥18岁且患有cGVHD相关硬化的成年人参加了半结构化访谈,以确定突出的症状和功能。还使用现有PRO中与硬化相关的症状和功能来促使讨论未自发提及的主题。使用归纳分析将重要的症状和功能(子代码)进行聚类,并映射到总体领域(代码),并制定了候选项目。认知访谈用于评估项目、回答选项、回忆期和受访者说明的内容效度。进行了36次开放式访谈直至饱和,揭示了患者cGVHD相关硬化经历的广度,包括5个总体领域:(1)皮肤变化,(2)症状,(3)情绪和社会功能,(4)活动受限,(5)活动限制。通过认知反馈访谈(n = 25)对54个项目进行了测试并反复完善。对措辞进行了修改以提高相关性和理解性。删除了1个项目,并添加了2个项目以回应受访者的反馈,最终形成了55个项目。结果支持临时的李氏症状量表 - 皮肤硬化的相关性、可理解性和全面性。概念激发和认知访谈为李氏症状量表 - 皮肤硬化的开发提供了信息。正在外部队列中进行心理测量测试和确定最小临床重要差异,以验证这些PRO。