Smith-Greenaway Emily, Weitzman Abigail, Lungu Eric
Department of Sociology, Dana and David Dornsife College of Letters Arts and Sciences, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA 90089, USA.
Department of Sociology, College of Liberal Arts, The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX 78712, USA.
Popul Dev Rev. 2024 Dec;50(4):1117-1147. doi: 10.1111/padr.12682. Epub 2024 Nov 24.
Despite declines in child mortality rates, experiencing a child death remains a common feature of motherhood in many contemporary African populations. Yet, we lack population insights into the consequences of child death for mothers' well-being in the high-mortality regions where it concentrates. Contrasting an extensive psychology literature on the severe and long-lasting consequences of child death for parents in low-mortality settings, a long-standing thesis in multiple social science literature is that the normativity of child death in high-mortality settings can lead to a numbing effect-muting parents' reactions to child loss. Yet, select anthropological accounts challenge this thesis, arguing instead that child death can also bear notable consequences for bereaved parents in communities where it is common. This study brings population data to bear, analyzing two representative samples of women in Balaka, Malawi, to examine if child death has measurable mental health consequences for mothers, including elevated and/or worsening depressive symptoms. Further, the study explores the potential influence of children's near-death experiences on mothers. The results offer evidence that child loss-and the ever-present threat of it-are underappreciated drivers of women's poor mental health, and overall well-being.
尽管儿童死亡率有所下降,但在许多当代非洲人群中,经历孩子死亡仍是为人母的一个常见现象。然而,在儿童死亡集中的高死亡率地区,我们缺乏关于儿童死亡对母亲幸福感影响的人群见解。与大量关于儿童死亡在低死亡率环境中对父母造成严重且长期影响的心理学文献形成对比的是,多学科社会科学文献中一个长期存在的论点是,高死亡率环境中儿童死亡的常态性会导致一种麻木效应——减弱父母对孩子夭折的反应。然而,一些人类学记录对这一论点提出了质疑,认为在儿童死亡常见的社区,孩子的死亡也会给失去孩子的父母带来显著影响。本研究运用人口数据,对马拉维巴拉卡的两个具有代表性的女性样本进行分析,以检验孩子死亡是否会对母亲产生可衡量的心理健康影响,包括抑郁症状加剧和/或恶化。此外,该研究还探讨了孩子濒死经历对母亲的潜在影响。结果表明,失去孩子以及这种情况一直存在的威胁,是导致女性心理健康不佳和整体幸福感低下的未得到充分认识的因素。