Lu S T, Lebda N, Michaelson S M, Pettit S
Radiat Res. 1985 Mar;101(3):413-23.
The nature of the response of the thyroid gland in animals exposed to microwave irradiation is controversial. An enlarged thyroid and an increase of radioiodine uptake in microwave workers have been reported. Absence of thyroid disorders has also been reported in other exposed populations. Animal experimentation has contributed to the controversy because both increased and decreased thyroid functions have been reported. The thyroxine concentration in rats as representative of thyroid function in animals exposed to 2.45-GHz, 120-Hz amplitude-modulated microwaves has been studied. Comparison was made between thyroxine concentrations in microwave- and sham-exposed rats by Student's t test. After a 1-hr exposure, an increased thyroxine concentration was found in rats exposed at 40 and 70 mW/cm2, but not at 1, 5, 10, 20, 50, or 60 mW/cm2. After a 2-hr exposure, increased thyroxine concentration was noted in rats exposed at 25, 30, and 40 mW/cm2, but not at 1, 5, 10, and 20 mW/cm2. After a 4-hr exposure, thyroxine concentration increased in rats exposed at 1 mW/cm2 and decreased in rats exposed at 20 mW/cm2; but changes were not noted at 5 or 10 mW/cm2. Other experiments included animals that were exposed once for 4 hr (0.1, 1, 10, 25, and 40 mW/cm2), sampled 24 hr after a 4-hr exposure (0.1, 1, 10, 25, and 40 mW/cm2), or exposed for 4 hr 3 times (1, 10, 20, 30, 40, and 55 mW/cm2) and 10 times (1, 10, 20, 25, 30, and 40 mW/cm2), to evaluate the consistency of the thyroxine response. None of the rats in these experiments displayed any alteration of thyroxine concentration, except that decreased thyroxine was noted in rats exposed at 40 mW/cm2 for the third time. These studies covered a long time span; rats from two commercial sources (BS and CR) were used and subjected to different numbers of exposures, and therefore these data were evaluated for their stability. Two factors could influence the result significantly, i.e., source of animal and number of sham exposures. Rats used in the 2-hr exposures were from two different commercial sources; rats from CR had a higher (but normal) thyroxine concentration than did rats from BS. Therefore the data of these animals were separated by commercial source for reevaluation. Instead of increased thyroxine concentration in rats exposed at 25, 30, and 40 mW/cm2, changes were not noted in any microwave-exposed rats. The influence of sham exposure revealed that appropriate concurrent control and specification of animal source are needed in longitudinal studies.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)
暴露于微波辐射的动物甲状腺的反应性质存在争议。有报告称微波工作者甲状腺肿大且放射性碘摄取增加。也有报告称其他暴露人群未出现甲状腺疾病。动物实验加剧了这一争议,因为既有甲状腺功能增强的报告,也有甲状腺功能减弱的报告。已对暴露于2.45千兆赫、120赫兹调幅微波的大鼠的甲状腺素浓度进行了研究,以此代表动物的甲状腺功能。通过学生t检验比较了微波照射组和假照射组大鼠的甲状腺素浓度。照射1小时后,暴露于40和70毫瓦/平方厘米的大鼠甲状腺素浓度升高,但暴露于1、5、10、20、50或60毫瓦/平方厘米的大鼠未出现这种情况。照射2小时后,暴露于25、30和40毫瓦/平方厘米的大鼠甲状腺素浓度升高,但暴露于1、5、10和20毫瓦/平方厘米的大鼠未出现这种情况。照射4小时后,暴露于1毫瓦/平方厘米的大鼠甲状腺素浓度升高,暴露于20毫瓦/平方厘米的大鼠甲状腺素浓度降低;但暴露于5或10毫瓦/平方厘米的大鼠未出现变化。其他实验包括让动物单次暴露4小时(0.1、1、10、25和40毫瓦/平方厘米),在4小时暴露后24小时取样(0.1、1、10、25和40毫瓦/平方厘米),或让动物暴露4小时3次(1、10、20、30、40和55毫瓦/平方厘米)和10次(1、10、20、25、30和40毫瓦/平方厘米),以评估甲状腺素反应的一致性。这些实验中的大鼠均未出现甲状腺素浓度的任何变化,只有第三次暴露于40毫瓦/平方厘米的大鼠甲状腺素浓度降低。这些研究跨越了很长时间;使用了来自两个商业来源(BS和CR)的大鼠,并进行了不同次数的暴露,因此对这些数据的稳定性进行了评估。有两个因素可能会对结果产生显著影响,即动物来源和假照射次数。2小时照射实验中使用的大鼠来自两个不同的商业来源;来自CR的大鼠甲状腺素浓度高于(但仍正常)来自BS的大鼠。因此,将这些动物的数据按商业来源分开进行重新评估。暴露于25、30和40毫瓦/平方厘米的大鼠并未出现甲状腺素浓度升高的情况,任何微波照射组的大鼠均未出现变化。假照射的影响表明,纵向研究需要适当的同期对照和明确动物来源。(摘要截选至400字)