Wright Nicky, Pearson Rebecca M, Crook Danielle, Bond Alice, Jewell Tom
Department of Psychology, Manchester Metropolitan University, Manchester, United Kingdom.
Centre for Academic Mental Health, Population Health Sciences, Bristol Medical School, University of Bristol, Bristol, United Kingdom.
Front Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2024 Mar 4;2:1214890. doi: 10.3389/frcha.2023.1214890. eCollection 2023.
Current observational methods to understand adolescent-parent interaction are limited in terms of ecological and content validity. We outline initial results and a protocol for future work from a programme of work to: (1) establish a new method for data capture of adolescent-parent interaction at home using wearable cameras and; (2) develop a new relevant and comprehensive observational micro-coding scheme. In Part 1, we report our completed preliminary work, comprised of an initial scoping review, and public engagement work. In Part 2, we present a protocol for the development of the new measure.
Part 1-We searched Pubmed for existing observational measures of adolescent-parent interaction for the scoping review. We also undertook public engagement work utilising a mobile research van, taken to multiple locations around Bristol, UK to engage with a variety of populations through interactive methods. Part 2-Our protocol describes plans for: (1) A systematic review of the psychometric properties of observational measures of adolescent-parent interaction; (2) Focussed public engagement workshops; (3) Harmonisation of information from existing coding schemes and literature with information from public engagement with adolescents and parents; (4) A pilot study to assess the acceptability and feasibility of the method; (5) Development of a coding scheme in consultation with expert and lay panels, and through real-life application to recorded videos from a pilot sample.
Scoping review: we identified 21 adolescent-parent observational schemes, of which eight used micro-coding and 13 used globalcoding schemes. The majority of micro-coding schemes were not developed specifically for adolescents. Most studies used conflict or problem-solving tasks, which may not adequately capture positive adolescent-parent interactions. The mobile van event received views from 234 young people and/or parents. Families were positive about taking part in research using headcams. "Trust" and "understanding" were most frequently reported as important adolescent-parent relationship constructs.
This work represents the first attempt to truly co-design a method to assess parenting in adolescence. We hope to develop an observational measure using novel technological methods that can be used across a range of research and therapeutic settings.
目前用于理解青少年与父母互动的观察方法在生态效度和内容效度方面存在局限性。我们概述了一项工作计划的初步结果和未来工作方案,该计划旨在:(1)建立一种使用可穿戴摄像头在家中捕捉青少年与父母互动数据的新方法;(2)开发一种新的相关且全面的观察微编码方案。在第1部分中,我们报告了已完成的初步工作,包括初步的范围审查和公众参与工作。在第2部分中,我们提出了开发新测量方法的方案。
第1部分——我们在PubMed上搜索了用于范围审查的青少年与父母互动的现有观察测量方法。我们还利用一辆移动研究车开展了公众参与工作,该车前往英国布里斯托尔周围的多个地点,通过互动方法与不同人群进行接触。第2部分——我们的方案描述了以下计划:(1)对青少年与父母互动观察测量方法的心理测量特性进行系统评价;(2)有针对性的公众参与研讨会;(3)将现有编码方案和文献中的信息与青少年和父母公众参与中的信息进行协调;(4)进行一项试点研究,以评估该方法的可接受性和可行性;(5)与专家小组和非专业小组协商,并通过对试点样本录制视频的实际应用来开发编码方案。
范围审查:我们识别出21种青少年与父母观察方案,其中8种使用微编码,13种使用整体编码方案。大多数微编码方案并非专门为青少年开发。大多数研究使用冲突或解决问题任务,这可能无法充分捕捉青少年与父母的积极互动。移动车活动收到了234名年轻人和/或父母的意见。家庭对使用头戴式摄像头参与研究持积极态度。“信任”和“理解”被最频繁地报告为重要的青少年与父母关系构成要素。
这项工作代表了首次真正共同设计一种评估青少年养育方式方法的尝试。我们希望开发一种使用新颖技术方法的观察测量方法,该方法可用于一系列研究和治疗环境。