Al Tannir Abdul Hafiz, Pokrzywa Courtney, Murphy Patrick B, Biesboer Elise A, Figueroa Juan, Karam Basil S, DeMoya Marc, Carver Thomas
Department of Surgery, Division of Trauma & Acute Care Surgery, Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA.
Trauma Surg Acute Care Open. 2024 Dec 31;9(1):e001464. doi: 10.1136/tsaco-2024-001464. eCollection 2024.
Bedside thoracic ultrasound (US) offers numerous advantages over chest X-ray (CXR) for identification of recurrent pneumothoraces (PTX) after tube thoracostomy (TT) removal. Technologic advancements have led to the development of hand-held devices capable of producing high-quality images termed ultra-portable US (UPUS). We hypothesized that UPUS would be as successful as CXR in detecting post-TT removal PTX and would be preferred by patients.
We conducted a single-center prospective, feasibility, study at a level I trauma center investigating the use of UPUS in patients with trauma with TT placement. UPUS images were obtained daily while the TT was in place and post-TT removal (ranging from 1 through 6 hours). A clinically concerning PTX on UPUS was defined as the absence of lung sliding on two or more intercostal spaces. Poststudy Likert surveys were administered to assess patient preferences.
Ninety-two patients were included in the analysis. The majority were men (87%), and the median age was 47 years. Thirty-five patients (36%) had discordant imaging findings. There were 11 clinically concerning PTX, of which 10 (91%) were detected on UPUS and 8 (73%) on CXR. Three patients required an intervention for post-pull PTX, all of whom were identified on UPUS. Eighty-four percent (N=70) of surveyed patients preferred UPUS over CXR with 92% reporting no discomfort with UPUS compared with 49% with CXR.
Bedside UPUS is preferred by patients and can successfully identify clinically concerning post-TT removal PTX. Implementation of UPUS as a post-TT removal diagnostic tool is a safe and effective alternative to CXR.
Level II, diagnostic tests or criteria.
对于胸腔闭式引流管(TT)拔除后复发性气胸(PTX)的识别,床旁胸部超声(US)相比胸部X线(CXR)具有诸多优势。技术进步促使了能够产生高质量图像的手持式设备的发展,即超便携式超声(UPUS)。我们假设UPUS在检测TT拔除后PTX方面与CXR同样成功,并且会更受患者青睐。
我们在一家一级创伤中心进行了一项单中心前瞻性可行性研究,调查UPUS在接受TT置入的创伤患者中的应用。在TT留置期间及拔除后(1至6小时)每天获取UPUS图像。UPUS上临床上可疑的PTX定义为两个或更多肋间间隙无肺滑动。研究结束后进行李克特量表调查以评估患者偏好。
92例患者纳入分析。大多数为男性(87%),中位年龄为47岁。35例患者(36%)存在影像学结果不一致的情况。有11例临床上可疑的PTX,其中10例(91%)在UPUS上被检测到,8例(73%)在CXR上被检测到。3例患者因拔除后PTX需要干预,所有这些患者在UPUS上均被识别。84%(n = 70)的受调查患者更喜欢UPUS而非CXR,92%的患者报告使用UPUS时无不适,而使用CXR时这一比例为49%。
床旁UPUS更受患者青睐,并且能够成功识别临床上可疑的TT拔除后PTX。将UPUS作为TT拔除后的诊断工具是CXR的一种安全有效的替代方法。
二级,诊断试验或标准。