Martinez Meghan C, Szwerinski Nina, Liang Su-Ying, Chan Sharon, de Bruin Monique, Stults Cheryl D
Palo Alto Medical Foundation Research Institute and Center for Health Systems Research, Sutter Health, Palo Alto, CA, USA.
Director of Genetic Counseling, Bay Medical Foundation, Sutter Health, Sunnyvale, CA, USA.
Inquiry. 2025 Jan-Dec;62:469580251314747. doi: 10.1177/00469580251314747.
While telegenetic counseling has increased substantially since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, previous studies reported concerns around building rapport, nonverbal communication, and the patient-counselor relationship. This qualitative evaluation elicited feedback from genetic counselors, referring clinicians, and patients from a single healthcare organization to understand the user-driven reasons for overall satisfaction and experience. We conducted 22 in-depth, semi-structured interviews with participants from all 3 groups between February 2022 and February 2023. Interview recordings were transcribed and analyzed using a pragmatic thematic approach. Participants across all groups felt the style and content of the genetic counseling visit lent itself perfectly to telegenetics specifically because of no physical exam component. Most patient and counselor participants expressed having the genetic counseling over phone or video had no impact on the patient-counselor relationship or the amount of trust and emotional connection they were able to achieve remotely. Preference for visit type can be influenced by in-person masking requirements impeding full facial expressions or expressing strong emotions over phone. All respondents expressed strong support for all modalities going forward. Counselors with broad experience across platforms should be the focus of future recruitment as should patient education around the nature of the genetic counseling visit and the accuracy of various testing options. Telegenetic programs should consider perspectives from all 3 groups to ensure that specific needs of each are addressed.
自新冠疫情开始以来,远程遗传咨询大幅增加,但此前的研究报告了围绕建立融洽关系、非语言沟通以及患者与咨询师关系等方面的担忧。这项定性评估从一个医疗组织的遗传咨询师、转诊临床医生和患者那里收集反馈,以了解用户驱动的总体满意度和体验的原因。我们在2022年2月至2023年2月期间对所有3组参与者进行了22次深入的半结构化访谈。访谈录音被转录并采用务实的主题方法进行分析。所有组的参与者都认为,由于没有体格检查环节,遗传咨询问诊的方式和内容非常适合远程遗传咨询。大多数患者和咨询师参与者表示,通过电话或视频进行遗传咨询对患者与咨询师的关系以及他们在远程能够建立的信任和情感联系没有影响。对问诊方式的偏好可能会受到当面戴口罩要求的影响,这会妨碍充分的面部表情或通过电话表达强烈情感。所有受访者都对未来所有方式表示大力支持。未来招聘应聚焦于具有跨平台广泛经验的咨询师,患者关于遗传咨询问诊性质和各种检测选项准确性的教育也应如此。远程遗传项目应考虑所有3组的观点,以确保满足每组的特定需求。