Anderson Aubree, Theophanous Rebecca G
Department of Emergency Medicine Duke University School of Medicine Durham North Carolina USA.
Durham VA Healthcare System Durham North Carolina USA.
Australas J Ultrasound Med. 2024 Dec 13;28(1):e12415. doi: 10.1002/ajum.12415. eCollection 2025 Feb.
INTRODUCTION/PURPOSE: Teleultrasound connects expert point-of-care ultrasound (POCUS) users with remote community and rural sites. Evolving technologies including handheld devices, upgraded image quality, and the ability to transmit over low bandwidth connections increase POCUS education, accessibility, and clinical integration. Potential teleultrasound venues include low-resource settings, prehospital care, and austere environments (high altitudes, microgravity, conflict zones, etc.). This scoping review assesses current teleultrasound uses and identifies implementation enablers and barriers.
Using the PRISMA-ScR checklist, PubMed, Embase, and Cochrane were searched on 16 August 2024 for teleultrasound studies. Two reviewers independently screened results and abstracted data using a data collection table. 165 articles met the following inclusion criteria: research studies describing teleultrasound, involving humans, including healthcare workers, with remote point-of-care or medical ultrasound use, in any setting, and in English.
Teleultrasound studies were reported in most specialties and across all continents. Most were prospective (100 studies), review articles (27), or case studies (14). Study quality was variable, with 28 high quality, 77 moderate, 54 low, and 6 very low (GRADE assessment tool). Common themes that emerged include (1) type of image transmission method utilised, (2) remote provider training and curriculum development, (3) feedback methods between expert and novice users, (4) technologies and devices used, and (5) enablers and barriers to guide future teleultrasound implementation and training strategies.
Overall, the teleultrasound literature is heterogeneous in setting, design, and quality outcomes. As teleultrasound technology evolves and the use expands, future studies should standardise protocols and ensure image quality fidelity to optimise remote patient care.
引言/目的:远程超声将现场即时超声(POCUS)专家用户与偏远社区及农村地区连接起来。包括手持设备、提升的图像质量以及通过低带宽连接进行传输的能力等不断发展的技术,提高了POCUS的教育水平、可及性及临床整合程度。远程超声的潜在应用场景包括资源匮乏地区、院前护理以及严苛环境(高海拔、微重力、冲突地区等)。本综述评估了当前远程超声的应用情况,并确定了实施的促进因素和障碍。
2024年8月16日,使用PRISMA-ScR清单在PubMed、Embase和Cochrane数据库中检索远程超声研究。两名评审员独立筛选结果,并使用数据收集表提取数据。165篇文章符合以下纳入标准:描述远程超声的研究、涉及人类(包括医护人员)、在任何环境下使用远程现场即时护理或医学超声且为英文。
大多数专业领域以及各大洲均有远程超声研究报告。大多数研究为前瞻性研究(100项)、综述文章(27篇)或案例研究(14篇)。研究质量参差不齐,其中28项高质量、77项中等质量、54项低质量以及6项极低质量(采用GRADE评估工具)。出现的共同主题包括:(1)所采用的图像传输方法类型;(2)远程提供者培训及课程开发;(3)专家与新手用户之间的反馈方法;(4)所使用的技术和设备;(5)指导未来远程超声实施和培训策略的促进因素和障碍。
总体而言,远程超声文献在研究背景、设计和质量结果方面存在异质性。随着远程超声技术的发展和应用范围的扩大,未来的研究应规范方案,并确保图像质量的保真度,以优化远程患者护理。