de Groot A C, Liem D H, Nater J P, van Ketel W G
Contact Dermatitis. 1985 Feb;12(2):87-92. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0536.1985.tb01059.x.
179 patients suspected of cosmetic allergy were patch tested with a series of 16 fragrance materials and 9 preservatives. In 67 patients (37.4%), 1 or more of these substances gave positive reactions. In the group of fragrance materials, the largest numbers of positive patch test reactions were seen to isoeugenol, oak moss, geraniol, alpha-amylcinnamic alcohol, and a mixture of alpha-amylcinnamic aldehyde and alpha-hexylcinnamic aldehyde. The fragrance mix in the ICDRG standard series detected nearly 80% of cases of contact allergy to fragrance materials other than its constituents. In the group of preservatives, Kathon CG and quaternium-15 scored the highest number of positive reactions. It is argued that the commonly used patch test concentrations of 2% for oak moss and geraniol may be too low to detect all cases of sensitization.
179名疑似化妆品过敏的患者接受了一系列16种香料和9种防腐剂的斑贴试验。67名患者(37.4%)对其中1种或更多物质产生了阳性反应。在香料组中,异丁香酚、橡苔、香叶醇、α-戊基肉桂醇以及α-戊基肉桂醛与α-己基肉桂醛混合物的斑贴试验阳性反应数量最多。ICDRG标准系列中的香料混合物检测出了近80%对其成分以外的香料物质接触过敏的病例。在防腐剂组中,凯松CG和季铵盐-15的阳性反应数量最多。有人认为,橡苔和香叶醇常用的2%斑贴试验浓度可能过低,无法检测出所有致敏病例。