Zhu Jane, Rathagirishnan Raahulan, Valiquette Chantal, Adibfar Alexander, Snell Laura
Temerty Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
Faculty of Health Sciences, Queen's University, Kingston, Canada.
Plast Surg (Oakv). 2025 Feb;33(1):172-178. doi: 10.1177/22925503231195023. Epub 2023 Sep 6.
Gaps remain in surgical education regarding the representation of skin tone diversity. To improve equity and prevent misdiagnosis leading to worsened health outcomes, efforts must be made to ensure educational photographs are representative of the diverse patient populations plastic surgery residents will be treated in their future practices. Four study investigators examined 96 h of recorded lecture seminars from a Canadian plastic surgery resident education curriculum from May 2020 to December 2021. Using Fitzpatrick skin type to codify skin tone, photographic images were individually classified and compared. Program lecturers and residents were invited to participate in an online anonymized survey to explore related perceptions of the curricula. A total of 1990 images were included for analysis. Of these, 83.2% were Fitzpatrick types I to III, 13.1% were Fitzpatrick types IV to V, and 3.7% were Fitzpatrick type VI. There was a statistically greater proportion of Fitzpatrick I to III compared to types IV to V ( < .01), and type VI ( < .01). Fleiss' Kappa was calculated to be 0.896, representing near-perfect agreement. In the survey, 61% (14/22) of faculty respondents believe they include enough diversity in their photographs, however, 46% (4 of 9) of resident respondents would like to see more diversity in lecturers' photographs. There is an underrepresentation of medium (Fitzpatrick types IV-V) and dark (Fitzpatrick VI) images in plastic surgery resident educational images. Providing a curriculum that represents diverse patient populations is crucial to enabling competency and equity of care, particularly in a highly visual field. Incorporating skin tone diversity into educational curricula should be a priority for all plastic surgery programs.
在外科教育中,关于肤色多样性的呈现仍存在差距。为了促进公平并防止误诊导致健康结果恶化,必须努力确保教育用照片能代表整形外科住院医师未来临床实践中将会治疗的多样化患者群体。四位研究调查员检查了2020年5月至2021年12月期间加拿大整形外科住院医师教育课程的96小时讲座研讨会记录。使用菲茨帕特里克皮肤类型对肤色进行编码,对照片图像进行单独分类和比较。邀请课程讲师和住院医师参与一项在线匿名调查,以探讨他们对课程的相关看法。总共纳入1990张图像进行分析。其中,83.2%为菲茨帕特里克I至III型,13.1%为菲茨帕特里克IV至V型,3.7%为菲茨帕特里克VI型。与IV至V型(<0.01)和VI型(<0.01)相比,菲茨帕特里克I至III型的比例在统计学上更高。计算得出的弗莱iss卡帕值为0.896,代表几乎完全一致。在调查中,61%(14/22)的教员受访者认为他们在照片中纳入了足够的多样性,然而,46%(9人中有4人)的住院医师受访者希望在讲师的照片中看到更多样性。在整形外科住院医师教育图像中,中等(菲茨帕特里克IV - V型)和深色(菲茨帕特里克VI型)图像的呈现不足。提供能代表多样化患者群体的课程对于实现护理能力和公平性至关重要,尤其是在一个高度可视化的领域。将肤色多样性纳入教育课程应是所有整形外科项目的优先事项。