O'Dwyer L, Murphy B, Davey M S, Morrissey D, Cassidy J T
Graduate Entry Medical School, University of Limerick, Co. Limerick, Republic of Ireland.
Department of Trauma & Orthopaedic Surgery, University Hospital Limerick, Dooradoyle, Co. Limerick, Republic of Ireland.
Musculoskelet Surg. 2025 Jan 30. doi: 10.1007/s12306-025-00886-w.
The aim is to identify the 50 most cited papers and thus the most influential papers pertaining to ACJ reconstruction, and specifically, analysing the level of evidence (LOE), article content, journals occurring, and countries represented within the 50 most cited. A search of the Web of Science database was carried out using the following terms: "Acromioclavicular joint" OR "AC joint" (Topic) AND Reconstruction OR Repair (Topic). The top 50 relevant articles were analysed in relation to citations, citation density, geographic origin of the article, year published, and article type. The articles were cited a total of 6053 times. The most cited article was cited 347 times. The highest citation density was 20.02, with a mean citation density of 7.71 ± 4.13. Seventy per cent of the articles involved clinical research, 74% of which involved level IV evidence. Fifty-two per cent of the articles were published in the American Journal of Sports Medicine (AJSM). Most authors originated from USA (n = 26 or 52%), followed by Germany (n = 14 or 28%). This study revealed a paucity of articles with higher LOE among the most cited. Eight of the top 10 are either theoretical or biomechanical studies, and one reports an examination technique. Only two of the top 10 reported outcomes following surgical intervention and can thus directly guide treatment. Future research in the area of ACJ reconstruction should focus on generating high-quality interventional studies capable of informing/impacting patient care. Publishing in journals such as AJSM or Arthroscopy may lead to more citations.
目的是识别关于肩锁关节(ACJ)重建被引用次数最多的50篇论文,从而找出最具影响力的论文,并具体分析这50篇被引用次数最多的论文的证据水平(LOE)、文章内容、发表期刊以及代表国家。使用以下检索词在科学网数据库中进行检索:“肩锁关节”或“AC关节”(主题)以及“重建”或“修复”(主题)。对排名前50的相关文章的引用次数、引用密度、文章的地理来源、发表年份和文章类型进行了分析。这些文章总共被引用6053次。被引用次数最多的文章被引用了347次。最高引用密度为20.02,平均引用密度为7.71±4.13。70%的文章涉及临床研究,其中74%涉及IV级证据。52%的文章发表于《美国运动医学杂志》(AJSM)。大多数作者来自美国(n = 26或52%),其次是德国(n = 14或28%)。本研究表明被引用次数最多的文章中高质量证据水平的文章较少。排名前十的文章中有八篇是理论或生物力学研究,一篇报告了一种检查技术。排名前十的文章中只有两篇报告了手术干预后的结果,因此可以直接指导治疗。ACJ重建领域的未来研究应专注于开展高质量的干预性研究,以指导/影响患者护理。在AJSM或《关节镜检查》等期刊上发表文章可能会获得更多引用。