Corpus-Espinosa Claudia, Mac Fadden Isotta, Del Carmen Torrejón-Guirado María, Lima-Serrano Marta
Faculty of Nursing, Physiotherapy, and Podiatry, Department of Nursing, Universidad de Sevilla, Avenzoar Street, 6, 41009, Seville, Spain.
Social Sciences Faculty, Department of Sociology, Universidad de Salamanca, Francisco Tomás y Valiente Avenue, no., 37071, Salamanca, Spain.
Prev Sci. 2025 Feb;26(2):204-221. doi: 10.1007/s11121-025-01779-x. Epub 2025 Jan 31.
Adolescence is a critical period for developing risk behaviors such as substance use, which can impact health in adulthood. Culturally adapted evidence-based programs (EBPs) are promising for prevention. This review explores the processes for culturally adapting EBPs targeting alcohol, tobacco, or cannabis use, and/or anxiety or depression in adolescents. We searched multiple databases, grey literature, and relevant websites for studies detailing the cultural adaptation process of EBPs. We then categorized common adaptation steps, classified adaptations using the cultural sensitivity model, identified prevalent adaptation techniques, and determined effectiveness assessment methods. We reviewed the cultural adaptation processes of 43 EBPs. These programs were implemented in schools (51%), followed by family settings (30%), community settings (14%), and multi-component settings (5%). Eleven key steps were identified across the documents: local needs assessment, program selection, understanding of the program's curriculum, advisory group establishment, first draft of initial adaptation changes, staff selection and training, pilot study, enhanced cultural adaptation, implementation, evaluation and monitoring, and dissemination. Most programs integrated both surface (e.g., use of local images, material translation) and deep adaptations (e.g., incorporation of cultural values like "familismo"). Despite the common use of the cultural sensitivity model, detailed adaptation frameworks were often lacking. The field has advanced, but clearer documentation is needed to improve research and practical application.
青春期是诸如物质使用等危险行为形成的关键时期,这些行为会对成年后的健康产生影响。文化适应性循证项目(EBPs)在预防方面颇具前景。本综述探讨了针对青少年酒精、烟草或大麻使用及/或焦虑或抑郁的文化适应性循证项目的过程。我们在多个数据库、灰色文献及相关网站中搜索了详细阐述循证项目文化适应过程的研究。然后,我们对常见的适应步骤进行了分类,使用文化敏感性模型对适应情况进行了分类,确定了普遍使用的适应技术,并确定了有效性评估方法。我们审查了43个循证项目的文化适应过程。这些项目在学校实施的占51%,其次是家庭环境(30%)、社区环境(14%)和多成分环境(5%)。在这些文献中确定了11个关键步骤:当地需求评估、项目选择、对项目课程的理解、咨询小组的设立、初步适应变化的初稿、工作人员的选择和培训、试点研究、强化文化适应、实施、评估与监测以及传播。大多数项目既整合了表面适应(如使用当地图片、材料翻译),也整合了深度适应(如纳入“家庭主义”等文化价值观)。尽管文化敏感性模型被普遍使用,但往往缺乏详细的适应框架。该领域已经取得了进展,但需要更清晰的文献记录来改进研究和实际应用。