Moroe Nomfundo, Nkosi Nothando, Sebothoma Ben
Department of Speech Pathology and Audiology, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2025 Feb 19;25(1):279. doi: 10.1186/s12913-025-12386-5.
Despite the critical need for speech therapists and audiologists to meet various healthcare demands, including those outlined in the National Health Insurance Bill, unemployment among these professionals in South Africa remains a growing concern. Previous studies indicate that 16% of newly graduated speech therapists and audiologists are unemployed within the first year after completing community service, with this figure increasing to 19% by the second year. However, little is known about the lived experiences of unemployment among these professionals.
To explore the lived experiences of unemployed speech therapists and audiologists after community service, including their perceptions of job creation efforts by the government, universities, and professional bodies and their reflections on their chosen field of study and considerations of alternative career paths.
A non-probability purposive sampling strategy was employed to recruit participants who met the inclusion criteria. Participants consisted of speech therapists and audiologists who were either currently unemployed or had experienced unemployment within the last five years. Semi-structured interviews were conducted online to collect qualitative data. Data were analysed qualitatively, following Braun and Clarke's thematic analysis.
Three key subthemes emerged from the data on the lived experiences of participants: (1) social and lifestyle changes, (2) mental health concerns, and (3) financial strain. Participants also shared their perspectives on job creation, emphasizing the need for universities to better prepare graduates for the private sector and for professional boards and heads of departments to advocate more effectively for the profession. Despite their challenges, participants expressed a strong commitment to their profession, with many seeking alternative roles within the field and expressing no regrets about their career choices.
The findings reveal the multifaceted challenges faced by unemployed speech therapists and audiologists in South Africa, spanning systemic, social, financial, and psychological domains. Participants' experiences highlight the importance of coordinated efforts by the government, universities, professional bodies, and the private sector to address unemployment and create sustainable career pathways.
This study highlights the urgent need for systemic interventions to support unemployed speech therapists and audiologists. Efforts must focus on enhancing graduate employability, promoting advocacy for job creation, and developing alternative opportunities within the profession. Addressing these issues is essential for aligning the workforce with the nation's healthcare needs and ensuring that speech therapists and audiologists can contribute effectively to the healthcare system.
尽管言语治疗师和听力学家迫切需要满足各种医疗保健需求,包括《国家医疗保险法案》中概述的那些需求,但南非这些专业人员的失业问题仍然日益严重。先前的研究表明,16%的新毕业言语治疗师和听力学家在完成社区服务后的第一年内失业,到第二年这一数字上升到19%。然而,对于这些专业人员失业后的生活经历知之甚少。
探讨社区服务后失业的言语治疗师和听力学家的生活经历,包括他们对政府、大学和专业机构创造就业机会努力的看法,以及他们对所选研究领域的反思和对替代职业道路的考虑。
采用非概率目的抽样策略招募符合纳入标准的参与者。参与者包括目前失业或在过去五年内经历过失业的言语治疗师和听力学家。通过在线进行半结构化访谈来收集定性数据。按照布劳恩和克拉克的主题分析法对数据进行定性分析。
从参与者生活经历的数据中出现了三个关键子主题:(1)社会和生活方式的变化,(2)心理健康问题,(3)经济压力。参与者还分享了他们对创造就业机会的看法,强调大学需要更好地让毕业生为私营部门做好准备,以及专业委员会和各部门负责人需要更有效地为该职业进行倡导。尽管面临挑战,参与者对自己的职业仍表现出坚定的承诺,许多人在该领域寻求替代角色,并且对自己的职业选择不后悔。
研究结果揭示了南非失业言语治疗师和听力学家面临的多方面挑战,涵盖系统、社会、经济和心理领域。参与者的经历凸显了政府、大学、专业机构和私营部门共同努力解决失业问题并创造可持续职业道路的重要性。
本研究强调迫切需要系统性干预措施来支持失业的言语治疗师和听力学家。努力必须集中在提高毕业生的就业能力、促进创造就业机会的倡导以及在该职业内开发替代机会上。解决这些问题对于使劳动力与国家医疗保健需求相匹配,并确保言语治疗师和听力学家能够有效地为医疗保健系统做出贡献至关重要。