McCarthy Elizabeth M, Dinneen Sean F, Byrne Molly, Morrissey Eimear C, Casey Dympna
Health Behaviour Change Research Group, School of Psychology, National University of Ireland, Galway, Ireland.
School of Medicine, National University of Ireland, Galway, Ireland.
PLoS One. 2025 Feb 21;20(2):e0316345. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0316345. eCollection 2025.
Young adults (18-25 years) with type 1 diabetes can have high blood glucose levels, increasing their risk of complications. The D1 Now intervention aimed to improve outcomes, using a young adult-centred approach, comprising three components: an interactive messaging system, agenda setting tool, and support worker. A pilot randomised controlled trial was conducted to assess acceptability and feasibility of this novel intervention.
To explore perceptions and experiences of young adults and healthcare staff participating in the intervention arms of the D1 Now pilot randomised controlled trial.
A descriptive qualitative approach using semi structured interviews was used to collect data between May 2020, and January 2021 from sixteen young adults and ten healthcare staff Interviews were conducted online using MS Teams. Thematic analysis was used to analyse the data. A patient and public involvement approach was used with the D1 Now Young Adult Panel deployed from the outset to design and contribute to the study. Both written consent in advance and verbal consent was given by all participants for the online interviews that were video and audio recorded according to individual participant preference.
Themes were developed separately for young adult and healthcare staff participants. Two themes were developed from the young adult data, 1) 'empowerment' and 2) 'perceptions and experiences of the intervention'. One theme was developed from the healthcare staff data, 'perceptions and experiences of delivering the intervention'. All participants highlighted that the agenda setting tool and the support worker empowered the young adults as they could focus the consultation process on what mattered most to them. However, the interactive messaging system was perceived as unsuitable by many mainly because the technology was outdated. Overall, the perceived impact of participating in the study was positive.
Understanding participants perceptions and experiences of taking part in the D1 Now intervention is crucial. The lessons learnt can be used to further refine and develop the intervention with a view to measuring its effectiveness, in a future definitive trial.
1型糖尿病的年轻成年人(18 - 25岁)血糖水平可能较高,这增加了他们出现并发症的风险。“D1 Now干预措施”旨在采用以年轻成年人为中心的方法改善治疗效果,该方法包含三个组成部分:一个交互式信息系统、议程设定工具和支持人员。开展了一项试点随机对照试验,以评估这种新型干预措施的可接受性和可行性。
探讨参与“D1 Now试点随机对照试验”干预组的年轻成年人和医护人员的看法及体验。
采用描述性定性方法,通过半结构化访谈,于2020年5月至2021年1月期间收集了16名年轻成年人和10名医护人员的数据。访谈通过微软团队在线进行。采用主题分析法对数据进行分析。从一开始就启用了“D1 Now年轻成年人小组”,采用患者和公众参与的方法来设计并参与该研究。所有参与者均提前书面同意并口头同意进行在线访谈,访谈根据个人参与者的偏好进行视频和音频录制。
分别针对年轻成年人参与者和医护人员参与者制定了主题。从年轻成年人的数据中得出了两个主题,1)“赋权”和2)“对干预措施的看法及体验”。从医护人员的数据中得出了一个主题,“实施干预措施的看法及体验”。所有参与者都强调,议程设定工具和支持人员赋予了年轻成年人权力,因为它们可以使咨询过程聚焦于对他们最重要的事情。然而,许多人认为交互式信息系统不合适,主要原因是技术过时。总体而言,参与该研究的感知影响是积极的。
了解参与者对参与“D1 Now干预措施”的看法和体验至关重要。吸取的经验教训可用于进一步完善和改进该干预措施,以便在未来的确定性试验中衡量其有效性。