Lee Chena, Lee Joonsung, Mandava Sagar, Fung Maggie, Choi Yoon Joo, Jeon Kug Jin, Han Sang-Sun
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology, Yonsei University College of Dentistry, Seoul, 03722, Republic of Korea.
Institute for Innovative in Digital Healthcare, Seoul, 03722, Republic of Korea.
Dentomaxillofac Radiol. 2025 May 1;54(4):302-306. doi: 10.1093/dmfr/twae063.
This study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of deep learning method for denoising and artefact reduction (AR) in zero echo time MRI (ZTE-MRI). Also, clinical applicability was evaluated by comparing image diagnosis to the temporomandibular joint (TMJ) cone-beam CT (CBCT).
CBCT and routine ZTE-MRI data were collected for 30 patients, along with an additional ZTE-MRI obtained with reduced scan time. Scan time-reduced image sets were processed into denoised and AR images based on a deep learning technique. The image quality of the routine sequence, denoised, and AR image sets was compared quantitatively using the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and qualitatively using a 3-point grading system (0: poor, 1: good, 2: excellent). The presence of osteoarthritis was assessed in each imaging protocol. Diagnostic accuracy of each protocol was compared against the CBCT results, which served as the reference standard. The SNR and the qualitative scores were compared using analysis of variance test and Kruskal-Wallis test, respectively. The diagnostic accuracy was assessed using Cohen's κ (<0.5 = poor; 0.5 to <0.75 = moderate; 0.75 to <0.9 = good; ≥0.9 = excellent).
Both the denoised and AR protocols resulted in significantly enhanced SNR compared to the routine protocol, with the AR protocol showing a higher SNR than the denoised one. The qualitative assessment also showed highest grade in AR protocol with statistical significance. The osteoarthritis diagnosis showed enhanced agreement with CBCT in denoised (κ = 0.928) and AR images (κ = 0.929) than routine images (κ = 0.707).
A newly developed deep learning technique for both denoising and artefact reduction in ZTE-MRI presented clinical usefulness. Specifically, AR protocol showed significantly improved image quality and comparable diagnostic accuracy comparable to CBCT. It can be expected that this novel technique would help overcome the current limitation of ZTE-MRI for replacing CBCT in bone imaging of TMJ.
本研究旨在评估深度学习方法在零回波时间磁共振成像(ZTE-MRI)中进行去噪和减少伪影(AR)的有效性。此外,通过将图像诊断结果与颞下颌关节(TMJ)锥形束CT(CBCT)进行比较,评估其临床适用性。
收集了30例患者的CBCT和常规ZTE-MRI数据,以及通过缩短扫描时间获得的额外ZTE-MRI数据。基于深度学习技术,将扫描时间缩短的图像集处理为去噪和AR图像。使用信噪比(SNR)对常规序列、去噪和AR图像集的图像质量进行定量比较,并使用三点分级系统(0:差,1:好,2:优)进行定性比较。在每个成像方案中评估骨关节炎的存在情况。将每个方案的诊断准确性与作为参考标准的CBCT结果进行比较。分别使用方差分析和Kruskal-Wallis检验比较SNR和定性评分。使用Cohen's κ评估诊断准确性(<0.5 =差;0.5至<0.75 =中等;0.75至<0.9 =好;≥0.9 =优)。
与常规方案相比,去噪和AR方案均显著提高了SNR,AR方案的SNR高于去噪方案。定性评估也显示AR方案的等级最高,具有统计学意义。骨关节炎诊断在去噪图像(κ = 0.928)和AR图像(κ = 0.929)中与CBCT的一致性高于常规图像(κ = 0.707)。
一种新开发的用于ZTE-MRI去噪和减少伪影的深度学习技术具有临床实用性。具体而言,AR方案显示出显著改善的图像质量和与CBCT相当的诊断准确性。可以预期,这种新技术将有助于克服ZTE-MRI目前在TMJ骨成像中替代CBCT的局限性。