即时奖励和延迟奖励对任务切换表现的影响。
The Impact of Immediate and Delayed Rewards on Task-Switching Performance.
作者信息
Zhao Guang, Wang Huijun, Wu Rongtao, Zhao Zixin, Li Shiyi, Wang Qiang, Sun Hong-Jin
机构信息
Faculty of Psychology, Tianjin Normal University, Tianjin 300387, China.
Department of Psychology, Neuroscience and Behaviour, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON L8S 4K1, Canada.
出版信息
Brain Sci. 2025 Jan 21;15(2):100. doi: 10.3390/brainsci15020100.
BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES: Switching between different tasks incurs switch costs. Previous research has demonstrated that rewards can enhance performance in cognitive tasks. However, prior studies have primarily focused on the overall improvement in cognitive task performance, with limited research on how different types of rewards function under various task conditions. This study aims to investigate the distinct effects of immediate and delayed rewards on cognitive task performance in different task conditions (repeated trials and task-switching trials) and to explore the underlying neural mechanisms, particularly focusing on how rewards influence attention allocation during the concurrent processing of multiple cues.
METHODS
This study recruited 27 college students (average age 19 years old, 10 males and 17 females). A cue-based task-switching paradigm incorporating immediate and delayed rewards was employed. The study examined the effects of immediate and delayed rewards on cognitive task performance in repeated trials and task-switching trials. Event-related potentials (ERPs) were recorded to investigate the neural mechanisms underlying reward effects on attention allocation.
RESULTS
Behavioral results indicated that immediate rewards significantly enhanced performance in repeated trials compared to delayed rewards. In contrast, no significant difference between immediate and delayed rewards was observed in task-switching trials. ERP results showed that immediate rewards induced a larger P300 amplitude than delayed rewards under the task repetition condition. No P300 difference was found between immediate and delayed rewards under the task-switching condition.
CONCLUSIONS
The findings suggest that rewards enhance task performance by optimizing the allocation of attention to the ongoing task when multiple cues are processed concurrently. When additional resources are required to process task-related cues, there may be insufficient remaining capacity to effectively process reward cues, which could be essential for the optimal completion of the task. These results support the Expected Value of Control (EVC) theory in task-switching scenarios.
背景/目的:在不同任务之间进行切换会产生切换成本。先前的研究表明,奖励可以提高认知任务的表现。然而,以往的研究主要集中在认知任务表现的整体改善上,对于不同类型的奖励在各种任务条件下如何发挥作用的研究有限。本研究旨在探讨即时奖励和延迟奖励在不同任务条件(重复试验和任务切换试验)下对认知任务表现的不同影响,并探索其潜在的神经机制,尤其关注奖励在多个线索并行处理过程中如何影响注意力分配。
方法
本研究招募了27名大学生(平均年龄19岁,男性10名,女性17名)。采用了一种包含即时奖励和延迟奖励的基于线索的任务切换范式。该研究考察了即时奖励和延迟奖励在重复试验和任务切换试验中对认知任务表现的影响。记录事件相关电位(ERP)以研究奖励对注意力分配影响的神经机制。
结果
行为结果表明,与延迟奖励相比,即时奖励在重复试验中显著提高了表现。相比之下,在任务切换试验中,即时奖励和延迟奖励之间未观察到显著差异。ERP结果显示,在任务重复条件下,即时奖励比延迟奖励诱发更大的P300波幅。在任务切换条件下,即时奖励和延迟奖励之间未发现P300差异。
结论
研究结果表明,当多个线索并行处理时,奖励通过优化对正在进行任务的注意力分配来提高任务表现。当需要额外资源来处理与任务相关的线索时,可能没有足够的剩余能力来有效处理奖励线索,而奖励线索对于任务的最佳完成可能至关重要。这些结果支持任务切换场景中的控制预期价值(EVC)理论。