Generating balanced populations of CD8 effector and memory T cells is necessary for immediate and durable immunity to infections and cancer. Yet, a definitive understanding of how a diverse CD8 T cell repertoire differentiates remains unclear. We identified several hundred T cell receptor (TCR) clonotypes that constitute the polyclonal response against a single antigen and found that a majority of TCR clonotypes were highly biased toward memory or effector fates. TCR-intrinsic biases were not stochastic and were dominant over environmental cues. Differential gene expression analysis of memory- or effector-biased TCR clonotypes showed bifurcation of differential fates at the early effector stage. Additionally, phylogenetic analysis revealed that memory-biased clonotypes retain their fate preferences in subclonal populations but effector-biased subclones can switch to a memory fate. Our study highlights that the polyclonal CD8 T cell response is a composite of unbiased and biased clonotypes with varying capacity to incorporate environmental cues in their cell fate decisions.