Lundheim Sigurd Hilmo, Löfström Erica
Department of Sociology and Political Science, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway.
Department of Psychology, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway.
Front Psychol. 2025 Feb 14;16:1386921. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2025.1386921. eCollection 2025.
In Norway, despite ambitious goals for a low-carbon society, the extensive extraction of fossil fuels persists, accompanied by widespread climate skepticism. Wind energy is proposed as a solution but faces resistance.
This study examines the experiences of both developers and opponents of wind energy through qualitative interviews. Using appraisal theory, we classify emotional reactions, finding sadness and disgust as the most prominent negative emotions.
Additionally, fear and frustration were prevalent, reflecting tensions between wind energy and individual values. Emotional reactions vary widely and suggest that opposition to wind energy is multifaceted. Opponents exhibit stronger emotional responses, while developers, representing business interests, show less intense emotions. We identified 23 key triggers for these emotions, which often can be seen as disruptions caused by the development of wind energy. Engagement, comprising cognitive, affective, and behavioral elements, is essential to addressing these conflicts. Early engagement gives stakeholders the opportunity to influence the process, thereby reducing the conflict level. This highlights the need for earlier and more inclusive engagement processes to foster meaningful dialog and uphold democratic principles.
在挪威,尽管有着建设低碳社会的宏伟目标,但化石燃料的大规模开采仍在持续,同时伴随着广泛的气候怀疑论。风能被提议作为一种解决方案,但却面临阻力。
本研究通过定性访谈考察了风能开发者和反对者的经历。运用评价理论,我们对情感反应进行分类,发现悲伤和厌恶是最突出的负面情绪。
此外,恐惧和沮丧也很普遍,这反映了风能与个人价值观之间的紧张关系。情感反应差异很大,表明对风能的反对是多方面的。反对者表现出更强烈的情感反应,而代表商业利益的开发者则表现出较弱的情感反应。我们确定了引发这些情绪的23个关键因素,这些因素通常可被视为风能开发所造成的干扰。参与,包括认知、情感和行为要素,对于解决这些冲突至关重要。早期参与使利益相关者有机会影响这一过程,从而降低冲突程度。这凸显了需要更早、更具包容性的参与过程,以促进有意义的对话并维护民主原则。