Severe maternal morbidity in the high income setting: a systematic review of composite definitions.

BACKGROUND

Severe maternal morbidity (SMM) is an important indicator for the improvement of maternity care. Measurement of SMM varies, limiting global comparisons. To promote concordance we studied how SMM has been defined in epidemiological practice.

METHODS

Comprehensive composite definitions of SMM in pregnancy or up to 6 weeks postnatal that captured both obstetric and non-obstetric processes in high-income settings were identified through a prospectively registered (PROSPERO CRD42023421377) systematic search of PubMed, Embase, and Google Scholar 01/01/1993-31/08/2024. Clinical concepts, diagnostic and procedural codes captured by definitions of SMM were compared and the variation between definitions was described.

FINDINGS

The initial search identified 7852 records and 40 studies were included: 28 studies that reported 32 definitions of SMM for use with administrative data, with median incidence of 11.4/1000, and 13 studies that reported 13 definitions for use with the primary medical record, with median SMM incidence of 6.7/1000. The majority of definitions included cardiac, respiratory, and renal dysfunction or failure; haemorrhagic, thrombotic or infective morbidity; and critical interventions. Up to 75% of cases of SMM under some definitions involved transfusion. The main source of variation between definitions was the selection and definition of common obstetric diagnoses. Variation in the sources of additional routine data required to construct a definition also limited comparability.

INTERPRETATION

Despite common approaches to defining SMM, there are opportunities to improve comparability. No two definitions for use with administrative data in different settings involved a similar incidence and set of components and involved a similar distribution of components among cases. Harmonization of the purpose, constituent codes, and sources of data would facilitate comparisons between maternity systems.

FUNDING

This work was supported by the Medical Research Council [MR/X006115/1] as well as the National Institute for Health Research [NIHR204430].