Dashti Seemin, Mahmoodi Hassan, Shaghaghi Abdolreza
Health Education and Promotion Department, Faculty of Health, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran.
Department of Nursing, Islamic Azad University (IAU), Ardabil Branch, Ardabil, Iran.
Health Promot Perspect. 2024 Dec 30;14(4):360-368. doi: 10.34172/hpp.43513. eCollection 2024.
Inclusion of palliative care (PalC) in the routine provided healthcare of hospitals is emphasized by the World Health Organization (WHO) in the endorsed Health Promoting Hospitals (HPH) initiative. Nonetheless, an evidence gap exists about explicit barriers and operational complexities that might prevent embeddedness of PlaC in the Iranian National Healthcare System (INHS) and this was the main impetus for the conception of the current research.
The Barry and Proops' recommended Q method procedures were used in 6 phases including concourse development through the scientific literature search and consultation with the 27 key informants, statements' selection, population set (P-set) selection, Q sorting and factor analysis. Principal component analysis and Varimax rotation were used in factor analysis and the values of factor loadings≥0.4 were considered satisfactory in assessing the degree to which a certain Q sort conforms to a particular factor.
The extracted four factors that accounted for 47% of the total observed variance were shortage of physical space and number of the healthcare providers (HCPs), inadequate involvement of the patient's family members in end-of-life treatment decisions, communication barriers, and inadequate training of HCPs for PalC provision.
This study elicited important barriers of incorporating PalC into the routine hospital care and hence, importance of taking a multifaceted approach for achieving the goals of INHS in quality healthcare provision. Contrasting views of the approached HCPs could help development of the evidence-based national policies concordant with the HPH initiative in Iran.
世界卫生组织(WHO)在认可的健康促进医院(HPH)倡议中强调,应将姑息治疗(PalC)纳入医院常规提供的医疗保健中。尽管如此,关于可能阻碍PalC融入伊朗国家医疗保健系统(INHS)的明确障碍和操作复杂性方面仍存在证据空白,这也是当前这项研究构思的主要推动力。
采用巴里和普罗普斯推荐的Q方法程序,分6个阶段进行,包括通过科学文献检索和与27名关键信息提供者协商来开展集合开发、陈述选择、人群集(P集)选择、Q分类和因子分析。因子分析中使用主成分分析和方差最大化旋转,在评估某个Q分类与特定因子的符合程度时,因子载荷值≥0.4被认为是令人满意的。
提取出的四个因子占总观察方差的47%,分别是物理空间和医疗服务提供者(HCPs)数量短缺、患者家庭成员在临终治疗决策中的参与不足、沟通障碍以及HCPs在提供PalC方面的培训不足。
本研究揭示了将PalC纳入医院常规护理的重要障碍,因此,采取多方面方法对于实现INHS在提供高质量医疗保健方面的目标具有重要意义。所涉及的HCPs的不同观点有助于制定与伊朗HPH倡议相一致的循证国家政策。