Wolfensberger Aline, Gendolla Sophie Cl, Dunaiceva Jelena, Plüss-Suard Catherine, Niquille Anne, Nicolet Anna, Marti Joachim, Powell Byron J, Naef Rahel, Boillat-Blanco Noémie, Mueller Yolanda, Clack Lauren
Institute for Implementation Science in Health Care, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
Department of Infectious Diseases and Hospital Epidemiology, University Hospital Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
BMJ Open. 2025 Mar 5;15(3):e091285. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2024-091285.
Antimicrobial resistance is a major global health threat, driven largely by the misuse and overuse of antibiotics. Point-of-care (POC) tests for inflammatory biomarkers like procalcitonin (PCT) have shown promise in reducing unnecessary antibiotic prescriptions. The hybrid type II ImpPro trial aims to evaluate the implementation and effectiveness of POC-PCT on antibiotic prescriptions by primary care physicians (PCP) in French-speaking Switzerland. Implementation is planned to include a multifaceted strategy delivered mainly, but not exclusively, via PCP quality circles. Currently, little guidance exists on how to best tailor the implementation strategies to a specific context. This study protocol describes the comprehensive approach taken within ImpPro to develop a multifaceted and multilevel strategy for POC-PCT implementation.
Our mixed-methods participatory implementation research study consists of four phases: (1) determinant identification; (2) determinant prioritisation; (3) implementation strategy ideation and (4) implementation strategy selection and refinement. All phases of the study will be guided by well-established implementation theories, models and frameworks. For 1, to identify the possible barriers and facilitators for implementation, we will conduct semistructured interviews with stakeholders followed by deductive coding using the updated Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research and inductive thematic analysis. In 2, to identify the key determinants, we will conduct online focus group discussions and vote on the importance and changeability of determinants. In 3, we will conduct interviews and an expert brainstorming session, followed by deductively coding implementation ideas according to the Expert Recommendations for Implementing Change compilation. In 4, we will conduct focus group discussions with experts and stakeholders about the APEASE criteria (ie, affordability, practicability, (cost-)effectiveness, acceptability, side effects and safety and equity) of these strategies, followed by a rapid data analysis approach to select the implementation strategies.
This study does not fall within the scope of the Human Research Act, and the necessity for a formal evaluation was waived from the Cantonal Ethics Committee (Req-2023-00392). The results of our study will be shared among the Antimicrobial Stewardship in Ambulatory Care Platform network, published in peer-reviewed scientific journals, and will be presented at international and national conferences.
抗生素耐药性是全球主要的健康威胁,主要由抗生素的滥用和过度使用所致。降钙素原(PCT)等炎症生物标志物的即时检验(POC)在减少不必要的抗生素处方方面已显示出前景。II型混合式ImpPro试验旨在评估瑞士法语区初级保健医生(PCP)使用POC-PCT进行抗生素处方的实施情况及有效性。计划实施的内容包括一项多方面的策略,主要(但不仅限于)通过PCP质量改进小组来实施。目前,关于如何根据具体情况最佳地调整实施策略的指导意见很少。本研究方案描述了ImpPro中为制定POC-PCT实施的多方面、多层次策略而采取的综合方法。
我们的混合方法参与式实施研究包括四个阶段:(1)确定影响因素;(2)对影响因素进行优先级排序;(3)构思实施策略;(4)选择并完善实施策略。研究的所有阶段将以成熟的实施理论、模型和框架为指导。对于第1阶段,为了确定实施的可能障碍和促进因素,我们将对利益相关者进行半结构化访谈,随后使用更新后的《实施研究综合框架》进行演绎编码,并进行归纳主题分析。在第2阶段,为了确定关键影响因素,我们将进行在线焦点小组讨论,并就影响因素的重要性和可变性进行投票。在第3阶段,我们将进行访谈和专家头脑风暴会议,随后根据《实施变革专家建议汇编》对实施想法进行演绎编码。在第4阶段,我们将与专家和利益相关者就这些策略的APEASE标准(即可承受性、实用性、(成本)效益、可接受性、副作用及安全性和公平性)进行焦点小组讨论,随后采用快速数据分析方法选择实施策略。
本研究不属于《人类研究法》的范畴,州伦理委员会(Req-2023-00392)免除了进行正式评估的必要性。我们研究的结果将在门诊护理平台网络的抗菌药物管理中分享,发表在同行评审的科学期刊上,并将在国际和国内会议上展示。