Gottlieb Hanna, Seghers Laura, Leiva-Fernandez Francisca, Ghiciuc Cristina Mihaela, Hafez Gaye, Herdeiro Maria Teresa, Petrović Ana Tomas, Novais Teddy, Schneider Marie P, Dima Alexandra, Ekenberg Marie, Wettermark Björn
Department of Pharmacy, Faculty of Pharmacy, Uppsala University, Box 580, Uppsala, 751 23, Sweden.
Department of Pharmaceutical and Pharmacological Sciences, KU Leuven, Leuven, Belgium.
BMC Med Educ. 2025 Mar 5;25(1):339. doi: 10.1186/s12909-025-06909-1.
Many patients are not taking their medicines. It has substantial negative medical and economic consequences for patients and healthcare systems but there is limited knowledge on how medication adherence is integrated in medical education. This study seeks to investigate to what extent students in medicine, pharmacy and nursing in Europe are taught about medication adherence.
A cross-sectional online survey was distributed to 731 persons teaching relevant courses across 142 European universities between February and June 2024. The survey addressed definitions of adherence and The ABC Taxonomy; methods to support adherence, methods to identify and monitor non-adherence; consequences and outcomes of non-adherence, and methods applied in teaching. They were also asked to provide links to their curricula. Responses from quantitative questions were analyzed descriptively. Word frequency and qualitative thematic analysis was used for the curricula inventory and analysis of free-text answers, respectively.
In total, 212 participants from 114 universities in 34 countries completed the survey. Respondents agreed to similar level on the need to enhance medication adherence teaching, with 72% in pharmacy, 71% medical, and 59% agreement in nursing education. The most taught topic across educations was the clinical impact of non-adherence, according to 89% in pharmacy, 84% medical, and 76% in nursing education. The ABC Taxonomy was taught in more than half of all pharmacy (73%), nursing (60%) and medical education (52%). In the qualitative analysis of free text-answers respondents emphasized the value of early, mixed method teaching. They reported a lack of guidance in teaching medication adherence, causing inconsistency in the educational quality and depth. Time constraints were highlighted as a significant challenge, while interprofessional collaboration and use of medication adherence technologies were seen as opportunities, though not widely implemented in teaching. The curricula inventory showed a substantial variance in how medication adherence content was described.
There is a lack of consistent teaching on medication adherence in Europe, underlining the necessity to establish a unified curriculum incorporating the ABC taxonomy, and to include a more patient-centred approach to support medication adherence.
许多患者未按医嘱服药。这对患者和医疗保健系统产生了重大的负面医学和经济后果,但关于药物依从性如何融入医学教育的知识却很有限。本研究旨在调查欧洲医学、药学和护理专业的学生在多大程度上接受了关于药物依从性的教学。
2024年2月至6月期间,向欧洲142所大学的731名教授相关课程的人员开展了一项横断面在线调查。该调查涉及依从性的定义和ABC分类法;支持依从性的方法、识别和监测不依从的方法;不依从的后果和结果,以及教学中应用的方法。他们还被要求提供其课程的链接。对定量问题的回答进行描述性分析。词频分析和定性主题分析分别用于课程清单编制和自由文本答案分析。
来自34个国家114所大学的212名参与者完成了调查。受访者在加强药物依从性教学的必要性方面达成了相似程度的共识,药学专业为72%,医学专业为71%,护理教育专业为59%。各专业中讲授最多的主题是不依从的临床影响,药学专业为89%,医学专业为84%,护理教育专业为76%。超过一半的药学(73%)、护理(60%)和医学教育(52%)专业都讲授了ABC分类法。在对自由文本答案的定性分析中,受访者强调了早期混合方法教学的价值。他们报告称,在药物依从性教学方面缺乏指导,导致教育质量和深度不一致。时间限制被视为一项重大挑战,而跨专业合作和药物依从性技术的应用被视为机遇,尽管在教学中尚未广泛实施。课程清单显示,在如何描述药物依从性内容方面存在很大差异。
欧洲在药物依从性教学方面缺乏一致性,这凸显了建立一个纳入ABC分类法的统一课程,并采用更以患者为中心的方法来支持药物依从性的必要性。