Gouge Kaylee, Schadler Aric, Fletcher Kristen E
Third-Year Resident, Departments of Internal Medicine and Pediatrics, University of Kentucky College of Medicine.
Research Data Analytics Manager, Kentucky Children's Hospital, University of Kentucky.
MedEdPORTAL. 2025 Mar 11;21:11504. doi: 10.15766/mep_2374-8265.11504. eCollection 2025.
During clinical training, medical students frequently encounter angry patients and loved ones but feel inadequately prepared to de-escalate these encounters. This unpreparedness might contribute to feelings of shame and anger among medical students and burnout among practicing physicians. Challenging patient scenarios abound in the standardized patient (SP) literature, but no published didactic tool exists focusing exclusively on identification and nonpharmaceutical management of patient anger with a target audience of senior medical students.
We created a 2-hour SP-based communication workshop for senior medical students. Small groups of students and one SP role-played angry patient scenarios with themes commonly encountered by subinterns, which a single facilitator then debriefed. To assess session effectiveness, student participants ( = 311) completed a presurvey prior to the workshop and a postsurvey immediately after. One hundred ninety students also completed a summative postworkshop observed structured teaching exercise.
Comparison of pre- and postworkshop responses (254-259 paired-response items from 311 participants) revealed a statistically significant improvement in students' self-reported confidence in six metrics related to anger identification and de-escalation ( < .001). Students also demonstrated statistically significant improvement in their ability to appraise the utility of common phrases for managing patient anger ( < .001).
Equipping students with evidence-based communicative strategies like the NURSE mnemonic improves their confidence in angry patient/family encounters and helps them more effectively appraise appropriate communication strategies in those encounters. This workshop may protect against feelings of shame and anger and augment self-efficacy in students' transition to clinical duties.
在临床培训期间,医学生经常会遇到愤怒的患者及其家属,但他们觉得自己没有充分准备好缓和这些冲突。这种毫无准备的状态可能会导致医学生产生羞耻感和愤怒情绪,以及执业医师出现职业倦怠。标准化患者(SP)文献中有大量具有挑战性的患者场景,但尚未有专门针对高年级医学生识别和非药物处理患者愤怒情绪的教学工具出版。
我们为高年级医学生创建了一个基于标准化患者的2小时沟通工作坊。学生小组与一名标准化患者就实习医生常见的主题进行愤怒患者场景的角色扮演,然后由一名主持人进行总结汇报。为了评估课程效果,参与的学生(n = 311)在工作坊前完成了一项预调查,并在结束后立即完成了一项后调查。190名学生还完成了一项工作坊后的总结性观察结构化教学练习。
工作坊前后回答的比较(来自311名参与者的254 - 259对配对回答项目)显示,学生在与愤怒识别和缓和相关的六个指标上自我报告的信心有统计学上的显著提高(P <.001)。学生在评估用于处理患者愤怒的常用短语的效用方面也有统计学上的显著提高(P <.001)。
为学生提供诸如NURSE记忆法等循证沟通策略,可提高他们在面对愤怒患者/家属时的信心,并帮助他们在这些情况下更有效地评估适当的沟通策略。这个工作坊可能有助于防止羞耻感和愤怒情绪的产生,并增强学生向临床职责过渡时的自我效能感。