Ibáñez-Alda Javier, Mediero-Pérez María Carmen, Rabal-Soláns Ana, Nieto-Sánchez Iván
Alfonso X El Sabio University, Villanueva de la Cañada, Spain.
Complutense University of Madrid, Madrid, Spain.
BMC Oral Health. 2025 Mar 13;25(1):380. doi: 10.1186/s12903-025-05645-8.
Information presented in audiovisual format, is more effective in the retention of information by patients than traditional written methods. On the other hand, empathy in the transmission of information is a crucial element in the relationship between health professionals and patients. This study aimed to determine whether the presentation of information in audiovisual format in an affective and empathetic way, as is done in social networks, improves the knowledge acquired by orthodontic patients treated with aligners.
60 participants, which were equally randomized in 2 groups, took part in this pilot study. Two videos were created that delivered the same informative content about treatment with dental aligners. One video used non-technical and empathetic language, for the level of understanding of patients (empathic video: EG), and the other used technical (similar to that used in clinical practice) but non-empathetic language (non-empathetic video: N-EG). Thirty randomized participants watched the empathic video and another thirty watched the non-empathetic video, and then completed the same questionnaire to compare the information acquired. The relative frequencies of correct responses in each group, were analysed by means of cross-tabulations. The significance of the differences between the results of the two groups was calculated with the Chi-square test.
The questionnaire confirmed that 70% of the participants had no prior knowledge of aligners. The 66.7% of patients, had no relatives or close friends or family who had been previously treated with aligners. Also 75% of them, stated that they had not previously searched for information about aligners on the Internet. After viewing the videos, all patients were able to respond adequately to most of the questions asked, regardless of whether they had viewed the empathic (EG) or non-empathetic (N-EG) video. Significant differences (p < 0,05) were recorded in 2 questions classified as technical difficulty, in which the EG obtained better results in terms of knowledge acquired than the N-EG.
Showing audiovisual format information to patients, improves patients' understanding of orthodontic treatment with dental aligners. Empathy enhances acquired knowledge for unusual and unknown information.
视听形式呈现的信息,相较于传统书面方法,在患者信息留存方面更有效。另一方面,信息传递中的同理心是医疗专业人员与患者关系中的关键要素。本研究旨在确定,如社交网络那样以情感化且具同理心的方式以视听形式呈现信息,是否能提升接受隐形矫治器治疗的正畸患者所获取的知识。
60名参与者被等分为两组,参与了这项初步研究。制作了两个视频,传达关于牙齿隐形矫治器治疗的相同信息内容。一个视频使用非专业且具同理心的语言,以方便患者理解(具同理心视频:EG组),另一个使用专业语言(类似于临床实践中使用的)但缺乏同理心的语言(缺乏同理心视频:N - EG组)。30名随机分组的参与者观看具同理心视频,另外30名观看缺乏同理心视频,然后完成相同问卷以比较所获取的信息。通过交叉制表分析每组正确回答的相对频率。用卡方检验计算两组结果差异的显著性。
问卷证实70%的参与者此前对隐形矫治器一无所知。66.7%的患者没有亲属、密友或家人曾接受过隐形矫治器治疗。此外,75%的患者表示他们此前未在互联网上搜索过关于隐形矫治器的信息。观看视频后,所有患者都能充分回答大多数所提问题,无论他们观看的是具同理心(EG组)还是缺乏同理心(N - EG组)视频。在两个归类为技术难度的问题上记录到显著差异(p < 0.05),其中EG组在获取知识方面比N - EG组取得了更好的结果。
向患者展示视听形式的信息,可提高患者对牙齿隐形矫治器正畸治疗的理解。同理心能增强对不常见和未知信息所获取的知识。