YouTube 作为正畸透明牙套信息来源。
YouTube as a source of information about orthodontic clear aligners.
出版信息
Angle Orthod. 2020 May 1;90(3):419-424. doi: 10.2319/072419-491.1.
OBJECTIVES
To evaluate the content, reliability, and quality of videos about orthodontic clear aligners on YouTube.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Researchers used the Google Trends website to determine that the most frequently used search term for orthodontic clear aligners on the Internet was: "Invisalign." A search was then conducted on YouTube using the key word "Invisalign." From the first 140 results, 100 videos were selected for analysis. A 13-point content score was used to classify poor-content and rich-content videos, and the global quality scale (GQS) was used to examine quality of the videos. To evaluate reliability of the information, a five-question scale was used. The Mann-Whitney U-test, χ2 test, and Pearson correlation coefficients were used for statistical evaluations.
RESULTS
Of the YouTube videos, 33 were classified as rich content and 67 as poor content. Most videos (73%) were uploaded by laypeople, and most uploaders (71%) were women. The most commonly discussed content was instructions (65%), followed by procedure (57%) and pain (52%). Regarding the GQS, most of the videos were evaluated as moderate quality (51%). Compared with the poor-content video group, the rich-content video group had a significantly higher GQS score (P = .004). There was no significant difference between the poor-content and rich-content groups regarding information reliability (P > .05).
CONCLUSIONS
Video content on YouTube relating to aligner orthodontics was generally insufficient. The quality of videos was moderate, but the reliability of information was generally poor. Specialists should refer patients to reliable sources of information.
目的
评估 YouTube 上关于正畸隐形矫正器的视频的内容、可靠性和质量。
材料与方法
研究人员使用 Google Trends 网站确定互联网上最常搜索的正畸隐形矫正器的搜索词是:“Invisalign”。然后在 YouTube 上使用关键字“Invisalign”进行搜索。从前 140 个结果中,选择了 100 个视频进行分析。使用 13 点内容评分来对内容丰富的视频和内容匮乏的视频进行分类,并使用全球质量量表(GQS)来检查视频的质量。为了评估信息的可靠性,使用了一个五分制量表。使用 Mann-Whitney U 检验、χ2 检验和 Pearson 相关系数进行统计评估。
结果
在 YouTube 视频中,33 个被归类为内容丰富,67 个为内容匮乏。大多数视频(73%)由非专业人士上传,大多数上传者(71%)为女性。讨论最多的内容是说明(65%),其次是程序(57%)和疼痛(52%)。关于 GQS,大多数视频被评估为中等质量(51%)。与内容匮乏的视频组相比,内容丰富的视频组的 GQS 评分明显更高(P =.004)。在信息可靠性方面,内容匮乏的视频组和内容丰富的视频组之间没有显著差异(P >.05)。
结论
YouTube 上关于牙套正畸的视频内容普遍不足。视频质量为中等水平,但信息的可靠性普遍较差。专家应引导患者到可靠的信息来源。