Department of Orthodontics, Faculty of Dentistry, Erciyes University, Kayseri, Turkey.
Department of Pediatric Dentistry, Faculty of Dentistry, Erciyes University, Kayseri, Turkey.
Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2022 Sep;162(3):e123-e132. doi: 10.1016/j.ajodo.2022.06.013. Epub 2022 Jul 11.
This study aimed to evaluate the content, reliability, and quality of YouTube videos for early orthodontic treatment.
YouTube video searches were carried out using the keyword "early orthodontic treatment," which was determined using Google Trends. After sorting according to relevance, the first 120 videos were observed, and 61 videos were analyzed accordingly. Further, the general characteristics, uploader source, reliability score (RS), global quality scale (GQS), video information quality index, audiovisual quality, viewers' interaction index, viewing rate, and total information content score (TCS) data belonging to these videos were analyzed. Based on their reliability scores, videos were divided into 2 main groups (low and medium/high information content) accordingly.
It was found that 25 (41%) of the videos had medium/high information content, and 36 (59%) had low information content, respectively. Videos with medium/high information content were found to have long video durations, increased comments, and high TCS, GQS, RS, and video information quality index scores (P <0.05). The videos uploaded by doctors had increased comments, long duration, and high TCS, GQS, and RS scores (P <0.05).
The quality of the information provided by YouTube videos on early orthodontic treatment was generally insufficient. In addition, the information quality was high for videos uploaded by doctors.
本研究旨在评估有关早期正畸治疗的 YouTube 视频的内容、可靠性和质量。
使用 Google Trends 确定的关键词“早期正畸治疗”在 YouTube 上进行视频搜索。根据相关性进行排序后,观察前 120 个视频,并对其中的 61 个视频进行分析。此外,还分析了这些视频的一般特征、上传者来源、可靠性评分(RS)、全球质量评分(GQS)、视频信息质量指数、视听质量、观众互动指数、观看率和总信息量评分(TCS)数据。根据其可靠性评分,视频被分为 2 个主要组(低信息内容和中/高信息内容)。
发现 25 个(41%)视频具有中/高信息含量,36 个(59%)视频具有低信息含量。具有中/高信息含量的视频具有较长的视频时长、增加的评论以及较高的 TCS、GQS、RS 和视频信息质量指数得分(P<0.05)。由医生上传的视频具有较高的评论数、较长的视频时长和较高的 TCS、GQS 和 RS 得分(P<0.05)。
YouTube 视频中有关早期正畸治疗的信息质量普遍不足。此外,医生上传的视频信息质量较高。