Yamaguchi N, Watanabe S, Maruyama K, Okubo T
Jpn J Clin Oncol. 1985 Apr;15 Suppl 1:313-23.
This paper focused on methodological issues in the epidemiology of multiple primary cancer, especially on methods to evaluate the frequency of a second cancer. The incidence density is the most widely used measure in cancer epidemiology. However, the measure of incidence might be biased to some extent, because it might be affected by extraneous factors which are related to the detection of the second cancer. A better alternative is the measure of the prevalence of occult cancer. The authors have formulated the functional relationship between the prevalence of occult cancer and some variables which can be obtained from ordinary epidemiologic observations, such as the incidence density, the growth function, and the distribution of the diameters of the cancers which were clinically diagnosed. The formula was then applied to an epidemiologic study of multiple primary cancer in the digestive system. All the patients with cancer of the digestive system except the stomach treated in the National Cancer Center Hospital between 1962 and 1981 constituted the study group. Among 1,561 male and 714 female patients, gastric cancers were found as the second primary cancer in nine males and one female within 2 months after the first cancers were detected. All the first cancers in these 10 cases were esophageal cancers. The expected numbers of second gastric cancers were calculated as 4.55 in males and 1.20 in females by using the formula. The observed number exceeded significantly the expected number in males (p value = 0.042), which suggested that esophageal and gastric cancers might share some risk factor.
本文聚焦于多原发性癌症流行病学中的方法学问题,尤其关注评估第二种癌症发生频率的方法。发病密度是癌症流行病学中使用最广泛的指标。然而,发病率指标可能在一定程度上存在偏差,因为它可能受到与第二种癌症检测相关的外部因素影响。更好的替代指标是隐匿性癌症的患病率。作者已构建了隐匿性癌症患病率与一些可从常规流行病学观察中获得的变量之间的函数关系,如发病密度、生长函数以及临床诊断癌症的直径分布。该公式随后应用于消化系统多原发性癌症的流行病学研究。1962年至1981年期间在国立癌症中心医院接受治疗的除胃癌外的所有消化系统癌症患者构成研究组。在1561名男性和714名女性患者中,有9名男性和1名女性在首次癌症被检测出后的2个月内被发现胃癌为第二种原发性癌症。这10例患者的所有第一种癌症均为食管癌。使用该公式计算出男性第二种胃癌的预期病例数为4.55,女性为1.20。男性的观察病例数显著超过预期病例数(p值 = 0.042),这表明食管癌和胃癌可能存在一些共同的危险因素。