Oyeniyi Jacob F, Loving Bailey A, Almahariq Muayad F, Jawad Maha Saada, Dilworth Joshua T
Department of Radiation Oncology, Corewell Health William Beaumont University Hospital, Royal Oak, MI, USA.
Cancer Causes Control. 2025 Mar 19. doi: 10.1007/s10552-025-01978-5.
Disparities in various dimensions, including racial, in breast cancer treatment and outcomes are well established. A recent multi-institutional study reported a higher mean heart dose (MHD) in Black and minority women compared to White women who underwent left-sided breast/chest wall irradiation which translated into excess cardiac events and mortality. We evaluated the MHD of women treated in our institution and investigated whether institution-wide measures including the use of readily available but inconsistently adopted technologies can mitigate this disparity.
We identified 509 female patients treated with left-sided breast/chest wall irradiation with/without regional nodal irradiation (RNI). Details regarding cardiac dosimetry, deep-inspiratory breath-hold (DIBH) such as active breathing coordinator (ABC) use, breast size, internal mammary nodal (IMN) irradiation, and whether the treatment plan met boarding pass requirements and was peer reviewed were noted. MHD differences across racial groups were analyzed using Kruskal-Wallis test, while UVA and MVA linear regression analyses assessed influence of various factors on MHD.
MHD(Gy) was similar across racial groups; 1.38, 1.35, and 1.39 (p = 0.6) in Black, White, and other racial groups, respectively. Utilization of hypofractionation, cavity boosts, RNI, IMN irradiation, meeting boarding pass requirements, and peer review were similar. ABC usage (%) was 83/75/62 (p = 0.005), while median breast size(cc) was 1504/1904/1331 (p = 0.001) in White/Black/other women, respectively. On UVA and MVA, MHD differed with IMN treatment, boost and ABC use but not racial groups and varying breast sizes.
Despite anatomical differences such as breast size, achieving similar cardiac dose is feasible across racial groups by uniformly utilizing appropriate technology such as ABC, with standardized boarding pass constraints, and peer review of all cases. Further studies to identify factors that may cause varied cardiac morbidity rates despite similar cardiac dosimetry among racial groups are warranted.
乳腺癌治疗及预后在包括种族等多个维度上的差异已得到充分证实。最近一项多机构研究报告称,与接受左侧乳房/胸壁放疗的白人女性相比,黑人及少数族裔女性的平均心脏剂量(MHD)更高,这导致了额外的心脏事件和死亡率。我们评估了在我们机构接受治疗的女性的MHD,并调查了包括使用现成但未一致采用的技术在内的全机构措施是否可以减轻这种差异。
我们确定了509例接受左侧乳房/胸壁放疗并伴有或不伴有区域淋巴结照射(RNI)的女性患者。记录了有关心脏剂量测定、深吸气屏气(DIBH)(如主动呼吸协调器(ABC)的使用)、乳房大小、内乳淋巴结(IMN)照射以及治疗计划是否符合登机牌要求并经过同行评审的详细信息。使用Kruskal-Wallis检验分析不同种族组之间的MHD差异,而UVA和MVA线性回归分析评估各种因素对MHD的影响。
不同种族组的MHD(Gy)相似;黑人、白人和其他种族组分别为1.38、1.35和1.39(p = 0.6)。超分割、瘤腔加量、RNI、IMN照射、符合登机牌要求以及同行评审的使用率相似。ABC的使用比例(%)分别为83/75/62(p = 0.005),而白人/黑人/其他女性的乳房中位大小(cc)分别为1504/1904/1331(p = 0.001)。在UVA和MVA分析中,MHD因IMN治疗、加量和ABC的使用而有所不同,但与种族组和不同的乳房大小无关。
尽管存在乳房大小等解剖学差异,但通过统一使用ABC等适当技术、标准化的登机牌限制以及对所有病例进行同行评审,不同种族组实现相似的心脏剂量是可行的。有必要进一步研究以确定尽管种族组之间心脏剂量测定相似但可能导致不同心脏发病率的因素。