Cheng Qiqi, Humphrey Neil
Manchester Institute of Education, University of Manchester.
Eval Rev. 2025 Mar 24;49(5):193841X251329459. doi: 10.1177/0193841X251329459.
This brief report provides preliminary independent evidence of the efficacy of Football Beyond Borders (FBB), a targeted, school-based social and emotional learning (SEL) intervention for at-risk youth. FBB includes weekly SEL classroom sessions, activities on the football pitch, 1:1 therapy sessions, holiday support, and rewards trips. Propensity score matching and difference-in-differences estimation were used in a pre-test/post-test control group design to assess the impact of FBB on the mental wellbeing (assessed via the Short Warwick-Edinburgh Mental Wellbeing Scale, SWEMWBS) of participants designated at-risk ( = 46 aged 12-14, 78.3% male), passive learners ( = 72, aged 12-14, 84.7% male), and role models ( = 35, aged 12-14, 85.7% male), with matched control samples derived from a subset of the #BeeWell cohort study ( = 8015). A significant intervention effect was observed for at-risk youth, with FBB leading to an increase of approximately 2.4 SWEMWBS points ( = 0.44). No significant intervention effects were observed for passive learners or role models. These results indicate that FBB can improve the mental wellbeing of at-risk youth. Accordingly, an explanatory trial is warranted.
本简要报告提供了“超越国界的足球”(FBB)有效性的初步独立证据。FBB是一项针对高危青少年的、基于学校的社会情感学习(SEL)干预措施。FBB包括每周的SEL课堂教学、足球场上的活动、一对一治疗课程、假期支持和奖励旅行。在一项前测/后测对照组设计中,使用倾向得分匹配和差分估计来评估FBB对被指定为高危的参与者(n = 46,年龄在12 - 14岁,78.3%为男性)、被动学习者(n = 72,年龄在12 - 14岁,84.7%为男性)和榜样(n = 35,年龄在12 - 14岁,85.7%为男性)心理健康(通过简短的沃里克 - 爱丁堡心理健康量表,SWEMWBS评估)的影响,匹配的对照样本来自#BeeWell队列研究的一个子集(n = 8015)。观察到FBB对高危青少年有显著的干预效果,FBB使SWEMWBS得分增加了约2.4分(p = 0.44)。对于被动学习者或榜样,未观察到显著的干预效果。这些结果表明,FBB可以改善高危青少年的心理健康。因此,有必要进行一项解释性试验。