Marchi Guido, Cucchiara Federico, Gregori Alessio, Biondi Giulia, Guglielmi Giacomo, Serradori Massimiliano, Gherardi Marco, Gabbrielli Luciano, Pistelli Francesco, Carrozzi Laura
Pulmonology Unit, Cardiothoracic and Vascular Department, University Hospital of Pisa, Via Paradisa 2, 56124 Pisa, Italy.
Department of Surgical, Medical and Molecular Pathology and Critical Care Medicine, University of Pisa, 56126 Pisa, Italy.
J Clin Med. 2025 Mar 18;14(6):2062. doi: 10.3390/jcm14062062.
Non-expandable lung (NEL) occurs when the lung fails to fully re-expand after pleural fluid drainage, complicating management and limiting therapeutic options. Diagnosis, based on clinical symptoms, pleural manometry, and traditional imaging, is often delayed to the peri- or post-procedural stages, leading to improper management, complications, and higher healthcare costs. Therefore, early, pre-procedural diagnostic methods are needed. Thoracic ultrasound (TUS) has emerged as a non-invasive tool with the potential to enhance diagnostic accuracy and guide clinical decisions, yet, it remains inadequately studied within the context of NEL. We conducted a non-systematic narrative review using a structured methodology, including a comprehensive database search, predefined inclusion criteria, and QUADAS-2 quality assessment. This approach ensured a rigorous synthesis of evidence on TUS in NEL, with the aim of identifying knowledge gaps and guiding future studies. Non-invasive, real-time, bedside M-mode TUS has demonstrated efficacy in predicting NEL prior to thoracentesis by detecting an absent sinusoidal sign and reduced atelectatic lung movement. Emerging experimental techniques, including 2D shear wave elastography (SWE), speckle tracking imaging (STI) strain analysis, the lung/liver echogenicity (LLE) ratio, TUS assessment of dynamic air bronchograms, and pleural thickening evaluation, show additional potential to enhance pre-procedural NEL detection. However, all these methods have significant limitations that require further comprehensive investigation. Despite their significant promise, TUS modalities for early NEL detection still require rigorous validation and standardization before broad clinical use. A multimodal diagnostic approach, combining clinical manifestations, pleural manometry, radiologic and ultrasonographic findings, along with emerging techniques (once fully validated), may provide the most extensive framework for NEL. Regardless of advancements, patient-centered care and shared decision-making remain essential. Further research is needed to improve outcomes, reduce healthcare costs, and enhance long-term treatment strategies.
不可复张性肺(NEL)是指胸腔积液引流后肺未能完全复张的情况,这使得管理变得复杂并限制了治疗选择。基于临床症状、胸腔测压和传统影像学的诊断通常会延迟到操作期间或操作后阶段,导致管理不当、出现并发症以及医疗成本增加。因此,需要早期的操作前诊断方法。胸部超声(TUS)已成为一种非侵入性工具,有可能提高诊断准确性并指导临床决策,然而,在NEL的背景下,对其研究仍不充分。我们采用结构化方法进行了一项非系统性叙述性综述,包括全面的数据库检索、预定义的纳入标准和QUADAS-2质量评估。这种方法确保了对NEL中TUS证据的严格综合,目的是识别知识空白并指导未来的研究。非侵入性、实时、床边M型TUS已证明通过检测无正弦波征和肺不张肺运动减少,在胸腔穿刺术前预测NEL方面具有有效性。新兴的实验技术,包括二维剪切波弹性成像(SWE)、散斑追踪成像(STI)应变分析、肺/肝回声比(LLE)、动态空气支气管造影的TUS评估以及胸膜增厚评估,显示出在提高操作前NEL检测方面的额外潜力。然而,所有这些方法都有显著局限性,需要进一步全面研究。尽管前景广阔,但用于早期NEL检测的TUS模式在广泛临床应用之前仍需要严格验证和标准化。结合临床表现、胸腔测压、放射学和超声检查结果以及新兴技术(一旦完全验证)的多模式诊断方法,可能为NEL提供最广泛的框架。无论取得何种进展,以患者为中心的护理和共同决策仍然至关重要。需要进一步研究以改善治疗效果、降低医疗成本并加强长期治疗策略。