Csendes A, Braghetto I, Calvo F, De la Cuadra R, Velasco N, Schutte H, Sepulveda A, Lazo M
Am J Surg. 1985 Jun;149(6):765-70. doi: 10.1016/s0002-9610(85)80182-3.
The purpose of this study has been to review the late results of surgical treatment of 244 patients with endoscopically proved benign chronic gastric ulcer located 5 cm or less from the cardia. In five patients, a total gastrectomy with esophagojejunostomy was performed. Proximal gastrectomy was used in 3 patients, mesogastrectomy in 5 patients, a partial Schoemaker's procedure in 73 patients, Pauchet's procedure in 70 patients, and Csendes' procedure in 23 patients. Nonresective procedures were employed in 67 patients and included the Kelling-Madlener procedure in 23 patients, pyloroplasty alone in 10 patients, gastrojejunostomy alone in 4 patients, local or wedge excision of the ulcer in 9 patients, and vagotomy and pyloroplasty in 21 patients. The follow-up evaluation was performed in 91 percent of the patients (mean 9 years postoperatively, range 5 to 15 years), with emptying endoscopy in all nonresected patients. A high mortality was observed after total or proximal gastrectomy, as well as after nonresective procedures. After the other resective techniques, low postoperative morbidity and mortality were observed. No recurrent ulcer was seen after the resective procedures. Based on these results, we propose that when the ulcer is located 5 cm below the cardia, Schoemaker's or Pauchet's procedure should be performed; if the ulcer is located 2 cm or less from the cardia, Csendes' procedure or the Kelling-Madlener procedure should be employed.
本研究的目的是回顾244例经内镜证实为贲门5cm以内良性慢性胃溃疡患者的手术治疗远期结果。5例患者行全胃切除加食管空肠吻合术。3例行近端胃切除术,5例行胃系膜切除术,73例行部分朔梅克手术,70例行保谢手术,23例行森德斯手术。67例患者采用非切除手术,其中23例行凯林-马德莱纳手术,10例行单纯幽门成形术,4例行单纯胃空肠吻合术,9例行溃疡局部或楔形切除术,21例行迷走神经切断术加幽门成形术。91%的患者进行了随访评估(术后平均9年,范围5至15年),所有未切除患者均进行了排空内镜检查。全胃或近端胃切除术后以及非切除手术后均观察到高死亡率。其他切除技术术后发病率和死亡率较低。切除手术后未见复发性溃疡。基于这些结果,我们建议当溃疡位于贲门下方5cm时,应行朔梅克或保谢手术;如果溃疡位于贲门2cm以内,应采用森德斯手术或凯林-马德莱纳手术。