Rudoler David, Kaoser Ridhwana, Lavergne M Ruth, Peterson Sandra, Bolton James M, Dahl Matt, Gallant François, Good Kimberley P, Juda Myriam, Katz Alan, Morrison Jason, Mulsant Benoit H, Park Alison L, Tibbo Philip G, Zaheer Juveria, Kurdyak Paul
Faculty of Health Sciences, Ontario Tech University, Oshawa, Ontario, Canada.
Ontario Shores Centre for Mental Health Sciences, Whitby, Ontario, Canada.
Can J Psychiatry. 2025 Jun;70(6):511-523. doi: 10.1177/07067437251322404. Epub 2025 Mar 28.
ObjectiveTo examine the patterns in the supply and use of psychiatric services in 3 Canadian provinces: British Columbia, Manitoba, and Ontario.MethodsWe conducted a repeated cross-sectional analysis spanning fiscal years 2012/13 to 2021/22, using patient- and psychiatrist-level data aggregated into administrative health regions. Descriptive statistics and linear regression were used to assess patterns and relationships between the per capita number of psychiatrists ("supply") and measures of use of psychiatric services ("utilization"), including any psychiatrist contact, psychiatric consultation (1-2 visits with the same psychiatrist), and ongoing psychiatric care (3 or more visits with the same psychiatrist).ResultsThe number of psychiatrists per capita remained stable within the 3 provinces during the study period. In 2021/22, Vancouver had the highest number in British Columbia (45 psychiatrists per 100,000 individuals), compared to 14 per 100,000 in lower-supply regions. Toronto had the highest number in Ontario (38 per 100,000), compared to 9 in lower supply regions. Winnipeg had the highest number in Manitoba (25 per 100,000), compared to 7 in the lower supply regions. In 2021/22, the per capita number of psychiatrists was moderately correlated with any psychiatrist contact ( = 0.290) and ongoing psychiatric care ( = 0.411), but weakly correlated with psychiatric consultation ( = 0.005). The relationship between supply and utilization diminishes with higher levels of regional supply.ConclusionsPsychiatrists were unevenly distributed within and across provinces. While more psychiatrists are needed, the moderate and diminishing relationships between their numbers and utilization suggest that increasing this number alone is unlikely to fully address unmet needs for mental healthcare. Strategies to improve access will need to directly target uneven distributions. Further research is needed to understand the factors influencing psychiatrists' practice choices and ways to better support them in increasing their access to care.
目的
考察加拿大3个省份(不列颠哥伦比亚省、曼尼托巴省和安大略省)精神科服务的供应和使用模式。
方法
我们进行了一项重复横断面分析,涵盖2012/13财年至2021/22财年,使用汇总到行政卫生区域的患者和精神科医生层面的数据。描述性统计和线性回归用于评估精神科医生人均数量(“供应”)与精神科服务使用指标(“利用”)之间的模式和关系,包括与任何精神科医生的接触、精神科会诊(与同一位精神科医生进行1 - 2次就诊)以及持续的精神科护理(与同一位精神科医生进行3次或更多次就诊)。
结果
在研究期间,这3个省份的精神科医生人均数量保持稳定。2021/22年,温哥华在不列颠哥伦比亚省的精神科医生数量最多(每10万人中有45名精神科医生),而供应较低地区每10万人中有14名。多伦多在安大略省的精神科医生数量最多(每10万人中有38名),供应较低地区为每10万人中有9名。温尼伯在曼尼托巴省的精神科医生数量最多(每10万人中有25名),供应较低地区为每10万人中有7名。2021/22年,精神科医生人均数量与任何精神科医生接触(r = 0.290)和持续的精神科护理(r = 0.411)呈中度相关,但与精神科会诊(r = 0.005)呈弱相关。供应与利用之间的关系随着区域供应水平的提高而减弱。
结论
精神科医生在省内和跨省之间分布不均。虽然需要更多精神科医生,但他们的数量与服务利用之间的中度且逐渐减弱的关系表明,仅增加这一数量不太可能完全满足未得到满足的精神卫生保健需求。改善就医机会的策略需要直接针对分布不均的问题。需要进一步研究以了解影响精神科医生执业选择的因素以及更好地支持他们增加医疗服务可及性的方法。