Riva Fabiano, Wintermans Daan, Schaufelbühl Stefan, Fuchs Nadine, Kerkhoff Wim
University Center of Legal Medicine Lausanne, University Hospital Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Ecole Des Sciences Criminelles, Université de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Int J Legal Med. 2025 Mar 29. doi: 10.1007/s00414-025-03475-5.
Synthetic models (also called "surrogates") simulating human tissues are widely used in wound ballistics. Although there are a large number of commercial models showing interesting properties, these are limited to generic shapes. The result of the interaction between the projectile and the target varies based on several parameters; therefore, using a case-specific, custom-shaped synthetic model would enhance the accuracy of the findings. For this purpose, the authors created, based on Post-Mortem Computed Tomography (PMCT) measurements, case specific 3D-printed synthetic models. The first ballistic tests were performed on simple plates printed with different materials and compared against polyurethan Synbone® products in order to select the most suited materials for synthetic head models. Further tests were realised on head models printed with PLA (polylactic acid), PETG (polyethylene terephthalate glycol-modified) and TPU (thermoplastic polyurethane) polymers as well as on two head models composed of powder and resin. The bullet's behaviour, its deformation, the wound channel and other qualitative aspects were directly compared to the findings of the real case reported in Riva et al in Int J Legal Med 135:2567-2579, 2021, as well as to the "open shape" head model created by Riva et al in Forensic Sci Int 294:150-159, 2019. Finally, although the results of this study did not completely fulfil the requirements to simulate human bones, its concept in reproducing case specific head models with easily available 3D printing materials, is very promising.
模拟人体组织的合成模型(也称为“替代物”)在创伤弹道学中被广泛使用。尽管有大量具有有趣特性的商业模型,但这些模型仅限于一般形状。射弹与目标之间相互作用的结果会因几个参数而有所不同;因此,使用特定案例的定制形状合成模型将提高研究结果的准确性。为此,作者基于尸检计算机断层扫描(PMCT)测量创建了特定案例的3D打印合成模型。首先对用不同材料打印的简单板进行弹道测试,并与聚氨酯Synbone®产品进行比较,以选择最适合合成头部模型的材料。进一步的测试在使用聚乳酸(PLA)、聚对苯二甲酸乙二醇酯二醇改性物(PETG)和热塑性聚氨酯(TPU)聚合物打印的头部模型以及两个由粉末和树脂组成的头部模型上进行。子弹的行为、其变形、伤口通道和其他定性方面直接与Riva等人在《国际法律医学杂志》2021年第135卷:2567 - 2579页报道的真实案例结果进行比较,也与Riva等人在《法医学国际》2019年第294卷:150 - 159页创建的“开放形状”头部模型进行比较。最后,尽管本研究的结果并未完全满足模拟人体骨骼的要求,但其使用易于获得的3D打印材料复制特定案例头部模型的概念非常有前景。