Eberly Lauren A, Tennison Ada, Morgan Larissa, Smith Marita, Gray Leah, Kearney Matthew, Feliciano Benjamin, Lindsey Erica, Manche Jacob, Detsoi-Smiley Pamela, Shin Sonya, Merino Maricruz
Gallup Indian Medical Center, Indian Health Service, Gallup, NM (L.A.E., A.T., L.M., M.S., L.G., M.K., E.L., J.M., P.D.-S., M.M.).
Division of Cardiovascular Medicine, Department of Medicine, Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA (L.A.E.).
Circulation. 2025 Jul 15;152(2):101-112. doi: 10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.124.073166. Epub 2025 Mar 31.
The American Indian population in the United States experiences marked cardiovascular health disparities. American Indian patients, particularly those receiving care rurally through the Indian Health Service (IHS), face unique challenges to accessing appropriate cardiovascular care. However, there are no studies in the current era characterizing these challenges from the patient perspective. Therefore, the aim of this study was to characterize the barriers, facilitators, and perceptions of cardiac care among Diné (Navajo) patients with heart failure receiving care through the IHS, as well as to determine patient-designed solutions to improve access to quality cardiovascular care.
We performed semi-structured interviews and surveys of Diné patients (n=30) living with heart failure and receiving care at two IHS sites in rural Navajo Nation. The participants were 27% female and 30% Navajo speaking with a median age of 59 (interquartile range 53, 67) years. Interviews were guided by the Consolidation Framework for Implementation Research to describe patient experiences with receiving cardiac care. Interviews were audio recorded and transcribed for thematic analysis.
Several themes emerged reflecting barriers and facilitators to accessing cardiac care, as well as perspectives regarding heart failure care and advanced therapies. Primary barriers included lack of specialists locally, transportation-related and financial barriers to traveling long distances to urban centers for care, complicated IHS referral processes, and mistrust of providers outside of the IHS. Facilitators included trust of local IHS care; community and family support; and exceptional patient and caregiver resiliency and activation. Most patients felt that Traditional Medicine was important for their cardiovascular health and desired more of its integration into Western treatment. There was heterogeneity in cultural beliefs regarding heart transplantation, but the majority felt that it was acceptable if needed. Proposed solutions for improving cardiovascular care included making more services available locally, increased telehealth options, and assistance for social determinants of health, especially access to healthier food and transportation-related costs for referral care.
As the first qualitative study of American Indian patients with heart failure in the current era, these results highlight unique care challenges, which can inform community-designed strategies to improve access to care.
美国印第安人群体存在明显的心血管健康差异。美国印第安患者,尤其是那些通过印第安卫生服务局(IHS)在农村地区接受治疗的患者,在获得适当的心血管护理方面面临独特挑战。然而,当前时代尚无研究从患者角度描述这些挑战。因此,本研究的目的是描述通过IHS接受治疗的纳瓦霍族心力衰竭患者在心脏护理方面的障碍、促进因素和看法,并确定患者设计的改善优质心血管护理可及性的解决方案。
我们对居住在纳瓦霍族农村地区两个IHS机构且患有心力衰竭的纳瓦霍族患者(n = 30)进行了半结构化访谈和调查。参与者中27%为女性,30%会说纳瓦霍语,中位年龄为59岁(四分位间距53, 67岁)。访谈以实施研究整合框架为指导,描述患者接受心脏护理的经历。访谈进行了录音并转录以进行主题分析。
出现了几个主题,反映了获得心脏护理的障碍和促进因素,以及对心力衰竭护理和先进疗法的看法。主要障碍包括当地缺乏专科医生、前往城市中心就医的交通和经济障碍、IHS复杂的转诊流程以及对IHS以外医疗机构的不信任。促进因素包括对当地IHS护理的信任、社区和家庭支持,以及患者和护理人员非凡的适应能力和积极性。大多数患者认为传统医学对其心血管健康很重要,并希望更多地将其融入西医治疗。关于心脏移植的文化观念存在异质性,但大多数人认为如有需要是可以接受的。改善心血管护理的建议解决方案包括在当地提供更多服务、增加远程医疗选择,以及为健康的社会决定因素提供帮助,特别是获得更健康食品和转诊护理的交通相关费用。
作为当前时代对美国印第安心力衰竭患者的首次定性研究,这些结果突出了独特的护理挑战,可为社区设计的改善护理可及性的策略提供参考。