Zhang Dandan, Jia Yitong, Chen Yongjun, Liao Qingqing, Wang Meimei, Zhang Yin-Ping
Institute of Clinical Research, Affiliated Nanhua Hospital, Hengyang Medical School, University of South China, No. 336 Dongfeng South Road, Zhuhui District, Hengyang, 421002, Hunan, China.
School of Nursing, Xi'an Jiaotong University Health Science Center, No.76, Yanta West Road, Xi'an, 710061, Shaanxi, China.
BMC Nurs. 2025 Apr 3;24(1):364. doi: 10.1186/s12912-025-02898-0.
During the pandemic, China's control policies shifted from nationwide restrictions to precise control and monitoring, which ended with complete relaxation, presenting unique challenges for nurses. Existing qualitative studies mostly focused on the experiences of frontline nurses in the early stages of the pandemic, but they overlooked the dynamic nature of the role changes and adaptation processes as the pandemic evolved. In-depth research into nurses' experiences across different control phases is crucial for guiding future training to improve preparedness and policy enhancements.
To explore the experiences and challenges faced by frontline nurses in China during different phases of pandemic control policies. It also evaluates their training, reflects on the inadequacies of the training, and discusses how these experiences can inform future training programs while offering recommendations to enhance future emergency preparedness.
This study employed a qualitative descriptive design to explore the experiences and insights of nurses during the pandemic, as well as their attitudes toward training. Twenty-four frontline nurses from various hospitals in China were recruited using snowball sampling for in-depth interviews, which spanned two months. Data analysis was conducted using Giorgi's phenomenological approach, involving coding and theme extraction.
From a content analysis perspective, five main themes were extracted from different stages of control policies during the pandemic: (1) Nurses' feelings and responses: including early psychological stress and physical discomfort during the pandemic, adaptation and conflicts in isolation management during the rebound period, and later medical resource shortages. (2) Work achievements: covering a sense of mission, personal growth, and recognition. (3) Difficulties and challenges encountered: including initial workflow issues, resource shortages, critical care management gaps, communication barriers during the rebound period, and a decline in staff morale. (4) Training issues: rushed early training, limited content, lack of process and details during the rebound period, inconsistent standards, and lack of enthusiasm for participation. (5) Training improvement recommendations: suggesting an emphasis on training content, reasonable scheduling of training time, various forms of training, multiple assessment methods, and establishment of human resource reserves.
These findings reveal the challenges faced by frontline nurses during different phases of the pandemic, emphasizing the necessity of comprehensive and systematic nurse training programs. Recommendations include regularly updating training content, enhancing communication and psychological intervention training, diversifying training formats, establishing a mechanism for continuous learning, and exploring personalized training plans to improve nurses' preparedness in future public health crises.
在疫情期间,中国的防控政策从全国性限制转向精准防控与监测,最终全面放开,这给护士带来了独特的挑战。现有的定性研究大多聚焦于疫情早期一线护士的经历,但随着疫情演变,它们忽视了角色变化和适应过程的动态性。深入研究护士在不同防控阶段的经历对于指导未来培训以提高应对能力和完善政策至关重要。
探讨中国一线护士在疫情防控政策不同阶段所面临的经历与挑战。评估他们的培训情况,反思培训的不足之处,并讨论这些经历如何为未来培训项目提供参考,同时提出加强未来应急准备的建议。
本研究采用定性描述性设计,以探索护士在疫情期间的经历与见解以及他们对培训的态度。通过滚雪球抽样从中国各医院招募了24名一线护士进行为期两个月的深入访谈。采用 Giorgi 的现象学方法进行数据分析,包括编码和主题提取。
从内容分析的角度来看,在疫情期间防控政策的不同阶段提取了五个主要主题:(1)护士的感受与反应:包括疫情早期的心理压力和身体不适、反弹期隔离管理中的适应与冲突以及后期的医疗资源短缺。(2)工作成就:涵盖使命感、个人成长和认可。(3)遇到的困难与挑战:包括初期的工作流程问题、资源短缺、重症护理管理差距、反弹期的沟通障碍以及员工士气低落。(4)培训问题:早期培训仓促、内容有限、反弹期缺乏流程和细节、标准不一致以及参与积极性不高。(5)培训改进建议:建议强调培训内容、合理安排培训时间、采用多种培训形式、多种评估方法以及建立人力资源储备。
这些发现揭示了一线护士在疫情不同阶段所面临的挑战,强调了全面系统的护士培训项目的必要性。建议包括定期更新培训内容、加强沟通和心理干预培训、使培训形式多样化、建立持续学习机制以及探索个性化培训计划,以提高护士在未来公共卫生危机中的应对能力。