Willig Thiébaut-Noël, Bioulac Stéphanie, Blanc Jean-Paul, Bonnot Olivier, Caci Hervé, Chambry Jean, Charollais Aude, Desgrez Virginie, Doyen Catherine, Egaud Christine, Franc Nathalie, Girardon Dominique, Briant Fanny Gollier, Icick Romain, Joseph Françoise, Magnin Eloi, N'Diaye Claire, Ribeyrolle Jean-Luc, Surig Laurie, Purper-Ouakil Diane
Association française de pédiatrie ambulatoire (AFPA), 44150 Ancenis Saint-Géron, France; Occitadys, Toulouse, France.
Service universitaire psychiatrie de l'enfant et l'adolescent, hôpital couple enfant, CHU de Grenoble-Alpes - LPNC, CNRS UMR5105, université Grenoble-Alpes, Grenoble, France.
Encephale. 2025 Aug;51(4):437-446. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2025.01.002. Epub 2025 Apr 4.
This article examines international recommendations for the diagnosis and management of Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) in children and adolescents. It highlights the roles of physicians at various levels of care and introduces the 2024 recommendation from the French High Authority for Health (Haute Autorité de santé [HAS]) to create a formal certification for "ADHD-specialized physicians". These physicians would be qualified to both diagnose ADHD and initiate stimulant prescriptions. The article further outlines a proposed training framework for these specialized physicians in France, detailing the required training hours, educational objectives, and methods for evaluating competencies.
The study synthesized data from international guidelines on ADHD management collected through systematic searches conducted by the HAS between 2012 and 2023. This analysis focused on how physicians' roles are defined in different healthcare systems. In parallel, an inventory of training programs available in France in 2024 was conducted, categorizing these programs based on content and duration. Training modules were grouped into four categories: diplomas focused on ADHD, general training on neurodevelopmental disorders, introductory training for primary care physicians, and modules dedicated to therapeutic interventions for ADHD.
International recommendations exhibit significant variability in the delegation of diagnostic and treatment responsibilities for ADHD. Restrictive models, such as those in the UK and Germany, reserve diagnosis and stimulant initiation for specialists (e.g., child psychiatrists, pediatricians). In contrast, pragmatic approaches, exemplified by Canada and Australia, enable trained primary care physicians to handle straightforward cases. In France, the HAS has proposed an intermediate solution: recognizing "ADHD-specialized physicians" who can operate at a secondary care level. These physicians would manage ADHD diagnoses and initiate prescriptions, addressing challenges such as regional disparities in access to care, and the overburdening of specialist services. The proposed training framework for ADHD-specialized physicians includes 10-21hours of instruction. This program aims to equip physicians with skills in ADHD diagnosis, the identification of comorbidities, interpreting neuropsychological assessments, implementing psychoeducation, prescribing and monitoring pharmacological treatments, and coordinating with educational and healthcare teams. Additionally, it emphasizes non-pharmacological interventions, such as parental training programs and behavioral therapies. An additional component of the program would be a competency-based assessment using Script Concordance Tests (SCTs) designed to measure physicians' ability to apply knowledge in clinical scenarios.
The creation of ADHD-specialized physicians, as proposed by the HAS, represents a pivotal step in improving ADHD care in France. By addressing the gaps in access to diagnosis and treatment, this initiative aligns with successful elements of international models while tailoring solutions to the French healthcare context. A structured training framework and standardized assessment methods will ensure that these physicians can deliver high-quality care. Expanding access to pharmacological treatments through this approach has the potential to significantly reduce delays in ADHD management and enhance multidisciplinary collaboration. This initiative underscores the importance of harmonizing training, accreditation, and care delivery to meet the growing demand for ADHD services.
本文探讨了儿童和青少年注意力缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)诊断与管理的国际建议。它强调了各级医疗保健中医生的作用,并介绍了法国卫生高级管理局(Haute Autorité de santé [HAS])2024年的建议,即设立“ADHD专科医生”的正式认证。这些医生将有资格诊断ADHD并开具兴奋剂处方。本文还概述了法国针对这些专科医生的拟议培训框架,详细说明了所需的培训时长、教育目标以及能力评估方法。
该研究综合了HAS在2012年至2023年期间通过系统检索收集的关于ADHD管理的国际指南数据。该分析聚焦于不同医疗保健系统中医生角色的定义方式。同时,对2024年法国现有的培训项目进行了盘点,根据内容和时长对这些项目进行了分类。培训模块分为四类:专注于ADHD的文凭课程、神经发育障碍的通用培训、初级保健医生的入门培训以及ADHD治疗干预的专门模块。
国际建议在ADHD诊断和治疗责任的委托方面存在显著差异。像英国和德国那样的严格模式将诊断和兴奋剂开具保留给专科医生(如儿童精神科医生、儿科医生)。相比之下,以加拿大和澳大利亚为代表的务实方法使经过培训的初级保健医生能够处理简单病例。在法国,HAS提出了一种中间解决方案:认可能够在二级保健层面开展工作的“ADHD专科医生”。这些医生将负责ADHD诊断并开具处方,应对诸如医疗服务获取方面的地区差异以及专科服务负担过重等挑战。拟议的ADHD专科医生培训框架包括10至21小时的教学。该项目旨在使医生具备ADHD诊断、共病识别、解读神经心理评估、实施心理教育、开具和监测药物治疗以及与教育和医疗团队协调等技能。此外,它强调非药物干预,如家长培训项目和行为疗法。该项目的另一个组成部分将是使用脚本一致性测试(SCTs)进行基于能力的评估,旨在衡量医生在临床场景中应用知识的能力。
HAS提议设立ADHD专科医生,这是改善法国ADHD护理的关键一步。通过解决诊断和治疗获取方面的差距,这一举措与国际模式的成功要素相一致,同时根据法国医疗保健背景量身定制解决方案。结构化的培训框架和标准化的评估方法将确保这些医生能够提供高质量的护理。通过这种方式扩大药物治疗的可及性有可能显著减少ADHD管理中的延误并加强多学科协作。这一举措强调了协调培训、认证和护理提供以满足对ADHD服务不断增长需求的重要性。