Koenig Oliver, Mandl Sabine, Reisenbauer Simon
Bertha von Suttner Private University, St. Pölten, Austria.
Sociol Health Illn. 2025 May;47(4):e70035. doi: 10.1111/1467-9566.70035.
This article examines how vulnerability emerged, evolved and was contested during Austria's COVID-19 response, by attending to the entangled realities of people with dis/abilities. Using a posthumanist, agential realist lens and a diffractive methodology, the research explores how vulnerability is not a fixed state but a dynamic process shaped by material and discursive practices. It introduces the concept of 'vulnerability effects' to articulate that vulnerabilities are simultaneously a product of and a catalyst for material and discursive practices within systems of dis/ability and crisis response. Drawing on Carol Thomas's distinction between disablism and impairment effects, the analysis moves beyond binary framings to capture how vulnerabilities are simultaneously produced by systemic inequalities and contested through creative acts of resistance. Through the narratives of participants navigating institutional restrictions, inaccessible environments and intersecting crises, the article illustrates how debilitating conditions and activist affordances intra-act, shaping the possibilities for agency and resilience. The findings reveal the fluid, context-dependent and performative nature of vulnerability, challenging static paradigms in crisis response. By reframing vulnerability as relational and emergent, the article calls for inclusive and response-able approaches to policy and social structures that address systemic neglect and promote equitable opportunities.
本文通过关注残疾人群体的复杂现实情况,研究了奥地利应对新冠疫情期间脆弱性是如何出现、演变以及引发争议的。该研究采用后人文主义、能动实在论视角和衍射方法,探讨了脆弱性并非一种固定状态,而是一个由物质和话语实践塑造的动态过程。文章引入了“脆弱性效应”的概念,以阐明脆弱性既是残疾和危机应对系统中物质和话语实践的产物,又是其催化剂。基于卡罗尔·托马斯对残障歧视与损伤效应的区分,该分析超越了二元框架,以捕捉脆弱性是如何同时由系统性不平等产生,并通过创造性的抵抗行为受到挑战的。通过参与者在应对机构限制、无障碍环境及多重危机时的叙述,本文阐述了衰弱状况与行动能力是如何相互作用,塑造了行动和恢复力的可能性。研究结果揭示了脆弱性的流动性、情境依赖性和表演性本质,对危机应对中的静态范式提出了挑战。通过将脆弱性重新界定为具有关联性和涌现性的概念,本文呼吁在政策和社会结构方面采取包容且有回应能力的方法,以解决系统性忽视问题并促进公平机会。