Thomsen Reimar W, Mailhac Aurélie, Løhde Julie B, Pottegård Anton
Department of Clinical Epidemiology, Aarhus University and Aarhus University Hospital, Aarhus, Denmark.
Department of Biomedicine, Aarhus University, Aarhus, Denmark.
Diabetes Obes Metab. 2025 Apr;27 Suppl 2(Suppl 2):66-88. doi: 10.1111/dom.16364. Epub 2025 Apr 8.
Glucagon-like peptide-1 receptor agonists (GLP-1RAs) have emerged as key agents for weight management, based on their marked efficacy as observed in randomized controlled trials. While still limited, real-world studies on GLP-1RA use in populations with obesity are increasingly available. This narrative review discusses contemporary real-world evidence demonstrating the utilization, clinical and comparative effectiveness, and adverse effects of the currently approved GLP-1RA-based weight-loss therapies, that is, liraglutide, semaglutide and tirzepatide. The observed weight reduction in clinical practice overall tends to be lower than in randomized controlled trials; however, outcomes approach those seen in trials when focusing on highly adherent patients. Real-world studies demonstrate high discontinuation rates of GLP-1RAs (20%-50%) within the first year, and the use of much lower doses than those evaluated in clinical trials. Evidence from observational studies within type 2 diabetes or obesity populations suggests frequent gastrointestinal disturbances in GLP-1RA users, as also observed in trials, but no clear increase in risks of severe events like pancreatitis or pancreatic cancer, thyroid disorders, or depression and self-harm. Further evidence is needed to understand possible real-world associations of GLP-1RAs with eye disease and other rare outcomes. We provide 10 areas of particular importance for further research on GLP-1RA within the real-world space, including improved understanding of the exact drivers of early discontinuation and suboptimal dosing, studies of the effects of stopping GLP-1RA treatment, and investigations of clinical and cost-effectiveness for hard clinical outcomes in real-world settings, including not only cardio-reno-metabolic outcomes but also obesity-induced diseases like neuropsychiatric disease, cancer, musculoskeletal disease, and infections. PLAIN LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Recent advancements in weight-loss medications have sparked a lot of interest. The so-called GLP-1 receptor agonist medications (GLP-1RAs) have gained a lot of attention, because they have shown to be very effective, leading to significant weight loss in patients participating in clinical trials. GLP-1RAs, like liraglutide, semaglutide, and tirzepatide, help manage weight by mimicking hormones that control blood sugar and appetite. However, how these medications perform in real life can be different from the controlled settings of clinical trials, in which patients are carefully selected and their treatment plans closely followed. This literature review looks at how these medications are used and their effectiveness and safety in real-world settings. In real-life practice, GLP-1RAs are often less effective than in clinical trial conditions. This is usually because patients don't follow their medication plans as strictly as in trials. Real-world data shows that many patients use lower doses and do not stick to their treatment as strictly as participants in a controlled trial might, leading to less weight loss. However, those who do follow their plans closely can achieve results similar to those in trials. A major issue with GLP-1RAs is that many patients stop using them within the first year due to side effects or high costs of the medications, especially if not covered by insurance. Common side effects include nausea and digestive problems, which are the main reasons patients stop taking these treatments. These side effects are often manageable and decrease over time, and this reviews found no strong real-world evidence that GLP-1RAs cause severe side effects in many users. Despite these challenges, when GLP-1RAs are used effectively and consistently, they show substantial benefits in weight loss, most so the newest medications semaglutide and tirzepatide. These medications are also likely to help manage and prevent weight-related health conditions like type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease, but evidence for these beneficial outcomes is still scarce in real-world settings. The review emphasizes the need for more research to understand why many patients stop using these medications and how to improve dosing. It also calls for studies on the long-term effects of these therapies on various health outcomes, including mental health, cardiometabolic health, cancer, and rare conditions like eye diseases. Overall, while GLP-1RAs are a valuable tool for weight management, their real-world use requires careful consideration of individual patient factors, such as the ability to stick to treatment plans, manage side effects, and afford the medications. Further research will help make these treatments more effective for a wider range of people that need them.
基于随机对照试验中观察到的显著疗效,胰高血糖素样肽-1受体激动剂(GLP-1RAs)已成为体重管理的关键药物。关于GLP-1RAs在肥胖人群中使用的真实世界研究虽然仍然有限,但数量日益增多。本叙述性综述讨论了当代真实世界证据,这些证据证明了目前已获批的基于GLP-1RA的减肥疗法(即利拉鲁肽、司美格鲁肽和替尔泊肽)的使用情况、临床和比较有效性以及不良反应。在临床实践中观察到的体重减轻总体上往往低于随机对照试验;然而,当关注高度依从的患者时,结果接近试验中的情况。真实世界研究表明,GLP-1RAs在第一年的停药率很高(20%-50%),且使用的剂量远低于临床试验中评估的剂量。来自2型糖尿病或肥胖人群观察性研究的证据表明,GLP-1RA使用者经常出现胃肠道不适,试验中也观察到了这一点,但胰腺炎或胰腺癌、甲状腺疾病、抑郁症和自残等严重事件的风险没有明显增加。需要更多证据来了解GLP-1RAs在真实世界中与眼部疾病和其他罕见结果之间可能存在的关联。我们提供了在真实世界空间中对GLP-1RA进行进一步研究特别重要的10个领域,包括更好地理解早期停药和剂量不足的确切驱动因素、停止GLP-1RA治疗的影响研究,以及对真实世界环境中硬临床结局的临床和成本效益的调查,这些结局不仅包括心脏-肾脏-代谢结局,还包括肥胖引起的疾病,如神经精神疾病、癌症、肌肉骨骼疾病和感染。
减肥药物的最新进展引发了很多关注。所谓的GLP-1受体激动剂药物(GLP-1RAs)受到了很多关注,因为它们已被证明非常有效,能使参与临床试验的患者显著减重。像利拉鲁肽、司美格鲁肽和替尔泊肽这样的GLP-1RAs,通过模拟控制血糖和食欲的激素来帮助管理体重。然而这些药物在现实生活中的表现可能与临床试验的受控环境不同,在临床试验中患者经过精心挑选且严格遵循治疗方案。这篇文献综述探讨了这些药物在现实世界中的使用方式及其有效性和安全性。在现实生活实践中,GLP-1RAs通常不如在临床试验条件下有效。这通常是因为患者不像在试验中那样严格遵循用药计划。真实世界数据表明,许多患者使用较低剂量,并且不像对照试验参与者那样严格坚持治疗,导致体重减轻较少。然而,那些严格遵循计划的患者可以取得与试验中相似的结果。GLP-1RAs的一个主要问题是,许多患者在第一年内由于药物副作用或高成本(特别是如果未被保险覆盖)而停止使用。常见副作用包括恶心和消化问题,这是患者停止服用这些治疗的主要原因。这些副作用通常是可控的,并且会随着时间减少,并且该综述未发现有力的真实世界证据表明GLP-1RAs会在许多使用者中引起严重副作用。尽管存在这些挑战,当GLP-1RAs有效且持续使用时,它们在减肥方面显示出巨大益处,最新的药物司美格鲁肽和替尔泊肽尤其如此。这些药物也可能有助于管理和预防与体重相关的健康状况,如2型糖尿病和心血管疾病,但在现实世界环境中这些有益结局的证据仍然很少。该综述强调需要更多研究来理解为什么许多患者停止使用这些药物以及如何改善给药。它还呼吁对这些疗法对各种健康结局的长期影响进行研究,包括心理健康、心脏代谢健康、癌症以及眼部疾病等罕见病症。总体而言,虽然GLP-1RAs是体重管理的宝贵工具,但它们在现实世界中的使用需要仔细考虑个体患者因素,如坚持治疗计划的能力、管理副作用的能力以及支付药物费用的能力。进一步的研究将有助于使这些治疗对更广泛需要它们的人群更有效。