Molitor Vincent, Seiters Johanna Christina, Vollmar Horst Christian, Palm Rebecca
School VI - School of Medicine and Health Sciences, Carl Von Ossietzky University, Oldenburg, Germany.
Institute of General Practice and Family Medicine (AM RUB), Medical Faculty, Ruhr University Bochum, Bochum, Germany.
BMC Med Educ. 2025 Apr 7;25(1):493. doi: 10.1186/s12909-025-07078-x.
Health care professionals (HCPs) in nursing homes, such as nurses and general practitioners (GPs), indicate a need for delirium-specific education. However, establishing educational interventions in the nursing home setting is challenging. e-learning is one method of compensating for these difficulties. Therefore, this study aims to develop a curriculum for interdisciplinary e-learning to improve delirium-specific knowledge in HCPs in nursing homes.
Delirium-specific competencies were formulated on the basis of exploratory setting-independent literature. The competencies were assessed for relevance (very relevant, relevant, less relevant and not relevant) by an expert panel through a two-stage Delphi study that included an integrated workshop. A consensus was assumed if 80% of the experts rated a competence as very relevant or relevant in the first round. Competencies with approval ratings between 75% and 80% after the first round and/or that were critically commented upon were discussed in the subsequent workshop and assessed again in the second round. The competencies that received approval ratings below 75% in the first Delphi round were removed. In the second Delphi round, competencies that did not achieve at least 80% approval were ultimately excluded.
A total of 120 competencies were formulated, including 108 that addressed both disciplines, 4 addressed nurses, and 8 addressed GPs. Nineteen experts participated in the first Delphi round, after which n=92 (76.7%) of the competences were approved and n=18 (15%) were deleted. A total of 10 (8.3%) of the competencies were critically discussed by 10 experts in the subsequent workshop, of which 6 were deleted. Four competencies (3 addressed nurses and 1 GP) were evaluated by 11 experts in the second Delphi, 3 of which were confirmed (the competence addressing GPs was deleted). Overall, n=97 (81.2%) competencies were included in the final curriculum. Of these, n=64 (66%) addressed both disciplines, n=16 (16.5%) addressed nurses, and n=17 (17.5%) addressed GPs.
Delirium is an interdisciplinary challenge. Hence, the majority of our newly developed competencies address both disciplines. However, discipline-specific competencies must be addressed in the development of e-learning. A competence-based curriculum is a necessary basis for providing interdisciplinary e-learning for HCPs in nursing homes.
养老院中的医护人员,如护士和全科医生(GPs),表示需要针对谵妄的教育。然而,在养老院环境中开展教育干预具有挑战性。电子学习是弥补这些困难的一种方法。因此,本研究旨在开发一门跨学科电子学习课程,以提高养老院医护人员对谵妄的专业知识。
基于探索性的、与环境无关的文献制定了针对谵妄的能力标准。通过包括综合研讨会在内的两阶段德尔菲研究,由一个专家小组对这些能力标准的相关性(非常相关、相关、不太相关和不相关)进行评估。如果80%的专家在第一轮中将某一能力标准评为非常相关或相关,则认为达成了共识。第一轮后批准率在75%至80%之间和/或受到批判性评论的能力标准在随后的研讨会上进行讨论,并在第二轮中再次评估。在第一轮德尔菲研究中批准率低于75%的能力标准被剔除。在第二轮德尔菲研究中,最终排除了批准率未达到至少80%的能力标准。
共制定了120项能力标准,其中108项涉及两个学科,4项涉及护士,8项涉及全科医生。19名专家参与了第一轮德尔菲研究,之后92项(76.7%)能力标准获得批准,18项(15%)被删除。在随后 的研讨会上,10名专家对总共10项(8.3%)能力标准进行了批判性讨论,其中6项被删除。在第二轮德尔菲研究中,11名专家对4项能力标准(3项涉及护士,1项涉及全科医生)进行了评估,其中3项得到确认(涉及全科医生的能力标准被删除)。总体而言,97项(81.2%)能力标准被纳入最终课程。其中,64项(66%)涉及两个学科,16项(16.5%)涉及护士,17项(17.5%)涉及全科医生。
谵妄是一个跨学科的挑战。因此,我们新制定的能力标准大多涉及两个学科。然而,在电子学习的开发中必须考虑特定学科的能力标准。基于能力的课程是为养老院医护人员提供跨学科电子学习的必要基础。