Chan Alyssa Yenyi, Chan Felicia Jia Hui, Puah Lucas Jia Rong, Azamuddin Muhammad Bin Aman, Rajendram Priyanka, Tan Weng Mooi, Yong Yoek Ling, Hildon Zoe Jane-Lara
Saw Swee Hock School of Public Health, National University Health System, National University of Singapore, Singapore.
Ministry of Health Office for Healthcare Transformation, Singapore.
Health Expect. 2025 Apr;28(2):e70228. doi: 10.1111/hex.70228.
In an effort to improve population health, communities are being enabled to take charge of their health through the Movements for Health (M4H) programme in Singapore. The present study seeks to understand what characterises a health movement and explores health narratives which resonate over the different life stages.
A multi-component qualitative formative study was undertaken. Focus group discussions (FGDs, n = 12) and one semi-structured interview (altogether involving n = 52 individuals) were carried out with government and community implementation stakeholders, alongside go-along interviews (n = 24, involving 11 volunteers, 13 programme participants) and e-diaries (n = 37, with 22 programme participants and 15 volunteers).
Themes are reported in bold, with subthemes in italics. Health movement building was defined as an evolving process marked by co-creation, emotional investment and framed by a shared understanding founded on explicit theory. Furthermore, health movements were characterised as taking root in the community, needing a shared 'cause' to be self-sustaining. They should be able to garner momentum and be replicable, and thus ultimately far-reaching and inclusive of all walks of life. Themes cross-cutting life stages include concerns about chronic illness, which are not limited to seniors. Positive role modelling is crucial in encouraging hesitant participants towards healthier behaviours. Additionally, the importance of building supportive, emotional connections with implementers was emphasised. Priority areas for changing health behaviours and informing health literacy planning across various life stages have also been identified. For youths, mental health struggles, such as mood regulation issues, are prevalent and often exacerbated by parental invalidation. Adults tend to deprioritize social health due to responsibilities like breadwinning and childminding, coping through social connections forged among programme participants. Seniors expressed trepidation regarding their physical health, fearing a loss of independence and verbalising how limited mobility affects their ability to exercise and socialise.
The present study has provided insights into the early phases of the novel M4H community-led programmatic approach. Our findings defined health movements and health needs across the life course, whilst expanding on related theoretical and applied community development traditions.
This study mixes participatory data (i.e. go-along interviews) with other qualitative data to provide insights into the co-creation process of health movement building. The study also adopted a user-centred approach, and the content appropriateness of the programmes was fed back to the community-level implementers (i.e. Community Movement Champions [CMCs]) and the M4H administrating committee to inform future programming. Future CMCs have taken up the recommendations extracted from stakeholder engagement, where components on sleep, mental health, etc., have been added. Community coaches and commissioning stakeholders are involved in authorship.
为了改善民众健康状况,新加坡通过“健康运动”(M4H)项目让社区能够自主管理自身健康。本研究旨在了解健康运动的特点,并探索在不同生命阶段引起共鸣的健康叙事。
开展了一项多成分定性形成性研究。与政府和社区实施利益相关者进行了焦点小组讨论(FGD,共12组)和一次半结构化访谈(共涉及52人),同时进行了随行访谈(24次,涉及11名志愿者、13名项目参与者)和电子日记记录(37份,其中22份来自项目参与者,15份来自志愿者)。
主题以粗体显示,子主题以斜体显示。健康运动建设被定义为一个不断发展的过程,其特点是共同创造、情感投入,并以基于明确理论的共同理解为框架。此外,健康运动的特点是扎根于社区,需要一个共同的“事业”来实现自我维持。它们应该能够积聚动力并具有可复制性,从而最终影响深远并涵盖各行各业。贯穿生命阶段的主题包括对慢性病的关注,这并不局限于老年人。积极的行为示范对于鼓励犹豫不决的参与者采取更健康的行为至关重要。此外,强调了与实施者建立支持性情感联系的重要性。还确定了在不同生命阶段改变健康行为和为健康素养规划提供信息的优先领域。对于年轻人来说,心理健康问题,如情绪调节问题很普遍,并且常常因父母的否定而加剧。成年人由于挣钱养家和照顾孩子等责任,往往将社会健康置于次要地位,通过项目参与者之间建立的社会联系来应对。老年人对自己的身体健康表示担忧,担心失去独立性,并表达了行动不便如何影响他们锻炼和社交的能力。
本研究为新型的由M4H社区主导的项目方法的早期阶段提供了见解。我们的研究结果界定了生命历程中的健康运动和健康需求,同时扩展了相关的理论和应用社区发展传统。
本研究将参与性数据(即随行访谈)与其他定性数据相结合,以深入了解健康运动建设的共同创造过程。该研究还采用了以用户为中心的方法,并将项目的内容适宜性反馈给社区层面的实施者(即社区运动倡导者[CMC])和M4H管理委员会,以为未来的项目规划提供参考。未来的CMC采纳了从利益相关者参与中提取的建议,增加了关于睡眠、心理健康等方面的内容。社区教练和委托利益相关者参与了论文撰写。